Feed on
Posts
Comments

“Those you seek are wolves. Wolves do not wish to be found, they are themselves the hunters, slipping between trees, out of eyesight, close to the ground. They survive, they thrive, on their cunning…They have been at their trade for hundreds of years. This way of life it is in their blood, their bones.”—comments made to Driver after he has suffered repeated attacks.

I make no secret of the fact that I think James Sallis is one of the best writers in the US today, regardless of genre. Though his novels recently have been firmly categorized as “American noir,” a genre I do not particularly enjoy because of the sometimes extreme violence, I do find Sallis’s writing style admirable, if not brilliant, for his ability to say much in few words and to convey tension without being melodramatic. His dialogue, usually terse, says all that needs to be said, and his ability to describe in perfect images of few words is unparalleled. “Minimalism” takes on new meaning in his hands. His earlier novels, such as the John Turner trilogy, combined under one title as What You Have Left, are noir interpretations of the Southern Gothic genre, and his recent novel The Killer is Dying is a unique combination of three separate stories of three separate characters whose lives just glance off each other near the end, and then continue on separately. That novel is compressed, every image counting, and his themes of man’s isolation are well developed through his vibrant characterizations.

His novel Drive, recently made into a hit film starring Ryan Gosling, precedes this novel, Driven, and both are short novels which lack the fully developed characters one finds in Sallis’s other novels. Drive, the story of a man who works as a stunt driver by day and as the driver of getaway cars by night, is full of violence, and the body count in the book and film is extremely high, some of the deaths coming at the hands of Driver himself as payback for egregious betrayals. At the end of the novel and film, Driver drives off, seriously wounded.

Driven begins six years later. Driver has been keeping a low profile under the pseudonym of Paul West in Phoenix, and he has been successful in avoiding trouble – and in falling in love with Elsa. The novel starts with a bang. On page one, Driver and Elsa are attacked, and though Driver manages to disable one attacker, the second one fatally stabs Elsa before Driver can take care of him. He has no idea who the attackers are and why he was selected for attack. He ends up going to Tempe, where he buys a 1970s Ford Fairlane and adapts it for the hard driving he expects he will have to do in the coming days. Several more attacks occur, always involving two people, always involving fatalities, but, still, Driver has no idea who is behind the attacks or why. Eventually, the trail leads to New Orleans, but his own connection there remains obscure. As one of Driver’s friends comments, “Do the dots connect? Could be all random. Separate storms. And in the long run what does it matter? The question’s always the same: What do you do? How do you act?…If you don’t want to carry through, you can go away again. Be missing.”

Driven is a peculiar book, one that feels unfinished to me. The back cover sports a sentence which I regarded at first as an obvious spoiler: “Driven tells how [Driver], done with killing, becomes the one who goes down ‘at 3 a.m. on a clear, cool morning in a Tijuana bar.’ ” Yet that scene never occurs in this novel, despite the misleading suggestion that it will be Driver’s fate.  It is a quotation from a screenplay which his friend Manny wrote years ago, and it has nothing whatever to do with this novel.   The novel, less than one hundred fifty pages long, with large type and wide margins, feels a bit like an outline, rather than the compressed but fully developed novel which Sallis is known for. The ending of this novel suggests that there might yet be another novel about the life of Driver.

Those who have not read Drive or seen the film will want to do so before reading this continuation of Driver’s story. And those who have never had the pleasure of reading Sallis at all may want to start with something else. (My own favorite among the recent books is The Killer is Dying, a terrific novel which is one of my Favorites of 2011, despite its noir focus.)  Though I enjoyed seeing what happens to Driver after Drive ends, this novel felt too abbreviated and too undeveloped, even for minimalist fiction, to stand with Sallis’s previous novels, at least to me. Time will tell if it, like Drive, is optioned for another film, and whether there is another novel in the works, making this part of a complete trilogy.

ALSO by Sallis:  DRIVE, DRIVE (the film),    THE KILLER IS DYING , and     WHAT YOU HAVE LEFT (which consists of all three novels on the Turner trilogy:  CYPRESS GROVE, CRIPPLE CREEK, and SALT RIVER).  Also, OTHERS OF MY KIND,       WILLNOT,    SARAH JANE

Photos, in order: The author’s photo by Karin Sallis appears on http://www.noexit.co.uk

The 1970 Ford Fairlane with “429 cubes” may be seen on http://www.musclecarclub.com

The photo of Ryan Gosling (Driver) may be found on the Drive Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/DriveTheMovie

ARC:  Poisoned Pen Press

DRIVEN, the sequel to DRIVE
REVIEW. Film connection, Mystery, Thriller, Noir, United States
Written by: James Sallis
Published by: Poisoned Pen Press
ISBN: 978-1464200113

Note: This debut novel by Edgardo David Holzman, published by Nortia Press, a new indie company, is one of the best debut novels I’ve read in years.  Don’t miss it.

“Could you live here and not suspect? People were disappearing right and left, all over the country. Not a handful. Thousands. They were being held in secret camps, tortured and murdered by the government – all with the complicity of the police, the courts, the Church. And they weren’t low-lifes nobody would miss. They were lawyers, students, factory workers, priests. They had families, bosses, employees, neighbors, friends. Didn’t people wonder?”

If this novel were a “thriller,” it might be possible to dismiss the horrors contained within it as fiction. Not so, with this book. This dramatic and heart-stopping novel recreates very real events of shocking, unimaginable brutality which take place in Argentina in the fall of 1979, three years after the end of the Peronist democracy, and you will not forget these events. After the military seizes power, the characters, as real as you and I, and with the same goals and dreams, have no alternative but to go about their lives trying to maintain a low profile, and as the atrocities continue, they soon affect these characters and the people they know and love. The novel becomes a revelation in which one cannot help but wonder, ultimately, how these atrocities were allowed to begin at all, and, even more importantly, how they were able to continue unimpeded within a country which was part of the Organization of American States. Was the belief, widely accepted outside Argentina, that subversives were trying to destabilize the country, and that dramatic steps were therefore needed to prevent anarchy, enough to justify the tortures and horrific deaths imposed on ordinary citizens? And why did no other country, especially the United States, ever sound the alarm?

That is the question at the heart of this novel by Edgardo David Holzman, who grew up in Argentina and graduated from law school there, then went to Washington, D.C., in 1974 to work for the Organization of American States. As part of a delegation investigating the human rights situation in Chile a year after the Pinochet coup, he came face to face with stories of unimaginable atrocities. When Argentina joined the list of countries with military dictatorships in 1976, they used the same enforcement methods as Chile had used.

Ultimately, Holzman decided to write a novel about the period, believing that “Fiction, paradoxically, is the closest thing we have to real life. It seeks to stir the heart as well as the head. It’s where readers can inhabit characters, feel what those characters feel, and experience their world.” With this novel Holzman fully achieves his goals, and few readers will emerge from this story unscathed – or unashamed. In Malena he recreates the period and its horrors by keeping the focus squarely on a series of characters whom the reader comes to know and, in most cases, like, people so closely resembling the reader, regardless of cultural differences, that identification with the characters is easy and natural. Their fates become the fates of our “friends,” and their futures become the hopes and dreams any civilized human being would have for them.

Kevin “Solo” Solorzano, an Argentine-born interpreter living in Washington, is sent to Buenos Aires to act as an interpreter for Admiral Rinaldi, Argentina’s Foreign Minister, during the visit of President Jimmy Carter. Rinaldi, very smooth, has hired an American PR firm for his speeches when he has been in the US, and he has spoken in the past to Senators Jesse Helms, Claiborne Pell, John Glenn, Bill Bradley, and Susan Sigal, a Representative from New York. Part of a delegation from the Organization of American States, Solo has not been to Argentina for sixteen years, but he looks forward to visiting with a dear friend, Malena Uriburu-Basavilbaso, daughter of a well-connected family and now the aide to the Ambassador to the US, and with Ines, a young woman he almost married when they lived together in New York City. Solo’s mentor, Alberto, in New York, has also asked him to take some money to his aunt and uncle in Argentina and see if he can find out what happened to their daughter, son, and daughter-in-law, who have disappeared.

At the same time, Captain Diego Fioravanti, a young soldier caught up in events that are moving too fast for him, witnesses the beating and horrific assassination of three “subversives.” Though he has been a protégé of Col. Indart, his squeamishness about the events he witnesses raises questions about his suitability for his job, and he will be put to increasingly traumatic tests to be sure that his humanity has been wiped out. Diego is the lover of Ines, Solo’s former fiancée.

As Solo’s life and his experiences with Ines and Malena, unfold, often dramatically, the reader comes to know Solo as a warm and caring man of great humanity. His visits to prisons, where some inmates have insisted on telling him what is really happening there (though they know they will undoubtedly be killed for telling him) torment him, and as he learns more about the active involvement of the Church in the massacres, about the secret deals that various officials have made with each other and with officials in the US and elsewhere, and about the tens of thousands of “desaparecidos” (“disappeared”) of whom there is no record at all, he is devastated. At the same time, he is also dealing with personal issues back home affecting his own family, while also investigating how his father drowned in a ship accident in Argentina sixteen years ago. The various characters come together when Diego, the unwilling soldier, is targeted for assassination.

Rich with history, the novel is populated by a large and well developed cast of characters. The reality of the events in which they find themselves is so horrific that every reader will cringe at what is happening to people with whom they can identify. The insights into the US position regarding the human rights abuses in these countries, and the secrecy with which they were treated are illuminating, as is the collusion of the Catholic Church in the abuses. Ranking among the best debut novels I have read in years, this novel is an incredible achievement, not only because of the subject matter, but because the pace and the plotting keep the reader on tenterhooks from beginning to end.

Photos, in order: The author’s photo appears on his publisher’s website: http://nortiapress.com/

The OAS headquarters in Washington, DC:  http://www.caribjournal.com

A woman marches, bearing witness to her missing children in Buenos Aires: http://mujereslibres.blogspot.com

On November 9, 2011, people gathered in Buenos Aires to await the verdict in the trial of twelve military officers accused of crimes against humanity carried out at the ESMA Navy Mechanics School, one of Latin America’s most notorious torture centers.  All twelve were declared guilty and sentenced to life imprisonment. http://mujereslibres.blogspot.com/

The U. S. Embassy in Buenos Aires:  http://www.msg-history.com

ARC:  Nortia

Note: This novel was SHORTLISTED for both the Booker Prize in 2009 and the Walter Scott Prize in 2010.

“I am a poet of space and form. Of light, of light and space and form. Architects are people who build walls and floors and roofs. I capture and enclose the space within…”—Rainer von Abt

While on their honeymoon in Venice, Czech citizens Viktor and Liesl Landauer meet architect Rainer von Abt at a party given by an acquaintance in an ancient palazzo. The next day he shows them display models of the dramatically different buildings he has been creating, and after indicating that he was once a student of Adolf Loos, who hails from their Czech city (known here as Mesto), he extols “the virtues of glass and steel and concrete, and decrie[s] the millstones of brick and stone that hung about people’s necks.” He believes that Mesto is now looking toward the future, and he wants to be part of it, explaining that “Ever since Man came out of the cave he has been building caves around him…But I wish to take Man out of the cave and float him in the air. I wish to give him a glass space to inhabit.” Viktor is enthralled, suggesting, “Perhaps you could design a Glass Space (Glasraum) for us.”

The house, von Abt believes, “should not look like something. It should just be, a shape without references.” Ultimately, the architect agrees to build the house, “But form without ornament is all I can give you…Here, in the most ornamental city in the whole world [Venice], I am offering you the very opposite.” And after he arrives in Mesto and surveys the site, with its slope down into a garden, he declares, “ I wish not just to design a house but to create a whole world. I want to work from the foundations to the interior, the windows, the doorways, the furnishings, the fabric of the place as well as the structure. I will design you a life. Not a mere house to live in, but a whole way of life…Your abode will be a work of art at which people will wonder.”

And so begins an enthralling tale in which the building of a spectacular and unusual house becomes the framework for a story about the social and political changes which occur in Eastern Europe between the two world wars, all of them affecting the fate of the house and the architect’s dream. But it is also a story of the family, Viktor and Liesl Landauer and their children, who build and live in the house. Though Liesl is a gentile, Viktor is Jewish, and when the National Socialists seize power in Austria and begin their campaign to dominate the Sudentenland of Czechoslovakia, Viktor quickly realizes that they must leave the house, the Glasraum they love, and sell his business (the famed Landauer motor cars) to Liesl’s Christian family, if they are to survive. “If you play with mad dogs, you are going to get bitten,” he declares.

Author Simon Mauer has always created exciting plots with important thematic overtones, and in this novel he outdoes himself, incorporating the broadest scope of any of his novels so far. Beginning in 1929, the story and the history of the house continue up to the 1990s, exploring the sociopolitical traumas of the era, from National Socialism through the Communist takeover, and the rebellion and eventual liberation of the country. Subplots and many secondary characters repeat throughout, connecting and reconnecting over the sixty-year time span. Viktor Landauer’s infidelities, including one with a woman who later becomes the nanny of his children and a friend of his wife, set the Nazi takeover into sharp relief, and his eventual arrival in the United States becomes a stopping point in the novel but not its conclusion.

Though Mawer never mentions the real house on which the novel is based, it is easily identifiable as the Tugendhat House, built by Ludwig Mies van der Rohe in what is now Brno, Czechoslovakia. The use of the “Landauer House” as a Nazi office building, a biological research lab, a temporary stable, and a gym for handicapped children, mostly polio victims, parallels some of the uses of the Tugendhat House, as does the eventual restoration of that house, which opened to the public on March 6, 2012.

Mawer’s pacing is flawless. He keeps the reader completely occupied as he explores the issues of the house and the Landauers’ relationship, their friendships (and/or infidelities), and their household staff, which stays behind when they leave. Hana Hanakova, Liesl’s close friend, a sexually adventuresome free spirit, apparently bisexual, expresses her genuine love for Liesl throughout. Even after Liesl leaves the house, Liesl and Hana remain in touch. Kata, hired as the nanny, is Viktor’s mistress, though she and Liesl become good friends, as do their children, with whom they share the Landauer House. Kata and Marika, her daughter, accompany the Landauers when they leave the house, becoming “six characters in search of a home.” Lanik, their untrustworthy chauffeur, assumes the role of caretaker of the abandoned house, eventually becoming an official with the Red Army. As time passes and the various characters make their peace with the circumstances in which they find themselves, for better or worse, the reader feels the whole weight of history unfolding, both politically and emotionally.

Focusing initially on the story of a great architectural achievement, the novel also explores several stories of love and betrayal; stories of love sanctioned, illicit, and forbidden; and the fraught history of Czechoslovakia (and peripherally, Austria) between the wars. Though few exact dates are provided, the novel reflects the growth of the Nazi movement, the exodus of those Jews fortunate enough to have the means to escape, and the aftereffects on the Landauers, their household, and on the Glass Room. Mawer’s prose is efficient, and his style keeps the reader on pace, never having to stop to figure out what the author “really” means. Filled with vibrant imagery, both of the external and internal worlds of the characters, the novel has something for everyone. Ultimately, the stories of all the characters are resolved, with only one loose end, and readers who enjoy this novel will want to reread the preface for further insights after completing the novel. A fully-developed and thoughtful novel with a unique focus and point of view.

Note:  A video showing the inside of this house may be found here: 

ALSO by Simon Mawer:  TRAPEZE.     TIGHTROPE,     PRAGUE SPRING

Photos, in order: The author’s photo appears on http://www.amazon.com

The Tugendhat Villa is shown on http://en.wikipedia.org

This black and white photo shows the “honey-colored” onyx wall (center), which features in the action of the novel.  Also shown, the piano (left), which is a motif which echoes throughout.   http://brnonow.com

The restored dining room and living room, on opposite sides of the onyx wall, are shown on as part of a story on http://www.architizer.com

THE GLASS ROOM
Review. Novel. Czechoslovakia/Czech Republic, Book Club Suggestions, Historical, Literary, Social and Political Issues, Architectural Video
Written by: Simon Mawer
Published by: Other Press
ISBN: 978-1590513965
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

Andrew Miller–OXYGEN

Note: This novel was SHORTLISTED for both the Booker Prize and the Whitbread Prize in 2001.

“…The day-to-day business of dying ran on relentlessly, a ferocious, semi-public labour.  What sense did it have beyond the workings of a certain crude biology?  What good lesson could be learned from watching someone die?  Was it just to throw you back harder against your own life, to make you see the necessity of getting on with it…a glib reminder that ‘soon you shall be as I am’?”

Revealing the final days of Alice Valentine, a former headmistress who is being attended by her sons and closest friends, Andrew Miller’s thoughtful novel Oxygen remains remarkably hopeful, never descending into the bathos of so many other end-of-life novels.  Alice’s dying, though realistically described, becomes, in fact, the fulcrum upon which the novel studies three other characters as they gain new insights into their own lives.  All of them have some “unfinished business” with which they have not come to terms, and as these characters focus their attention on Alice, while reminiscing privately about their own pasts, the novel goes far beyond the customary focus on the meaning of life and death to include each character’s secret failures, the guilt accompanying these, the nature of true happiness, and what it requires to become a “successful” human being.  Ultimately, Miller’s characters ask “Who are we?”  As Alice herself muses, “Was the ‘she’ who thought all [these things] just a brain that would die when the last of the oxygen was used up? Surely there was something inside, some inward shadow, the part that loved Mozart [perhaps].”

Alice’s elder son Larry, a handsome, well-built, former 1980 French Open tennis champion now living in the US, has starred in a TV series, now canceled.  His alcohol and cocaine consumption have jumped, leaving him in financial straits, and his marriage is in trouble. By keeping his California life secret from Alice, Larry remains the apple of her eye.  The least sensitive among the people at Brooklands, Larry wants to tell his mother that her vision of him is false – and the fact that he has sunk to a new low with his latest film project weighs heavily upon him.  He is “agitated by a great backlog of thinking. He could not decide whether there were a great many decisions to be made, or none at all; whether his situation warranted some explosion of energy, some drama of action, or if he should simply wait and see; if indeed there was nothing he could do that would make the slightest difference.”

Brighton Beach, where Alex was once found wandering

Younger son Alec, a thin aesthete, works as a translator for Laszlo Lazar, a Hungarian playwright living in Paris who is working on a new play.  At some point in the past, Alec has had a mini-breakdown, during which he was found wandering along Brighton Beach.  Despite his own problems and the pressure of his work, he has been attending his mother, though hard pressed to control his resentment of his favored older brother who has been unavailable for most of the emergencies involving her.  Still desperate for Alice’s praise, Alec has his mother’s best interests at heart, but he is squeamish about illness and the details of dying, and is guilt-ridden because he cannot make himself attend to all her physical needs.  “Though he had visions of [hugging her], making some show of his own pain, he did nothing, for fear that whatever he could say or show would be grossly inadequate.  For fear, too, perhaps, of what might happen if he did manage to express what he felt.”

Poster for the 1980 French Open at Roland Garros Stade

Laszlo Lazar, a Hungarian playwright living in Paris, fought during the Hungarian Freedom uprising and was the only one of his brigade to survive, but he feels guilty about a close friend whose death he blames on himself.  He tries to avoid looking back:  “How could he look back when there was only shame to look back on?  What pride could he take in consummate failure?…He wanted to forget forever.”  Though he has no direct connection with Alice, he is dependent upon Alec for his play, and Alec is not in London working.  The play, called Oxygene in French, provides a dominating image for the novel.  Requiring two sets, it is the story of a mining disaster in Eastern Europe, with action occurring both above the ground and beneath the ground.  As the oxygen in the mine runs out, the behavior of the desperate rescuers and the desperate miners becomes more frantic, with the play’s ending showing many parallels to what is happening at Alice’s bedside and within the psyches of Laszlo, Larry, and Alec.

Montparnasse Cemetery, visible from Laszlo Lazar’s apartment

As the action rotates among these characters, their interactions with each other reveal them beginning, individually, to look for ways to atone for their past failures, if atonement is necessary, and as Alice’s health begins to fail dramatically, their responses show them beginning to find new ways of behaving. The reader sees clearly how they all ache to be connected to a positive force which will give meaning to their lives (and, perhaps, end their nagging guilt about their failures), just as Alice improves when she is connected to oxygen.  Laszlo’s chance to atone for the past is particularly dramatic, and Alec’s is life-changing.

Institut du Monde Arabe in Paris

Despite its complex, seemingly depressing subject, the novel is actually thrilling to read, in part because of Andrew Miller’s skill as a novelist.  One of the clearest, cleanest writers in the world today, Miller chooses exactly the right word to meld perfect images with universal themes in new ways.  His characters feel real, and their behavior and internal crises feel “normal.”  (After all, who among us does not have regrets about certain aspects of our lives, or decisions we have made which we now regret, or opportunities we have squandered?)  Perhaps it is this reason that the book speeds along, despite its heavy subject matter.  Every detail is necessary to the overall story, and every detail works.  An elegant novel told simply.

Note: Miller’s debut novel, Ingenious Pain, won the prestigious IMPAC Dublin Award and the James Tait Black Memorial Prize, and Oxygen was shortlisted for both the Booker Prize and the Whitbread Award.  Pure won both the Costa Best Novel Award (formerly Whitbread Award) and the Costa Book of the Year Award in 2012.

ALSO by Miller (in addition to those in the Note above):  THE CROSSING.

Photos, in order: The author’s photo by Gretel Insignia appears on http://www.metro.co.uk

Brighton Beach, where Alex was found wandering, at one point, is shown here:  http://www.earth-photography.com

The poster for the 1980 French Open at Roland Garros Stade, is seen on http://en.wikipedia.org The tournament that year was actually won by Bjorn Borg.

Laszlo Lazar lives in Paris in an apartment building overlooking Montparnasse Cemetery, where Jean-Paul Sartre, Simone deBeauvoir, and Samuel Beckett are buried.  http://www.momondo.com

Laszlo meets someone who may help him change his life at Institut du Monde Arabe in Paris, shown here.  http://arquitectura.mapolismagazin.com

Note: This novel was nominated for the Arab Booker Prize.

Eat your chocolate, little girl;
Eat your chocolate!
Believe me, there are no metaphysics in the world beyond chocolate;
Believe me, all the religions in the world do not teach more than the sweetshop.
Eat, dirty girl, eat!—
“The Tobacco Shop” by Fernando Pessoa

In this complex, challenging, and unconventional novel, Iraqi author Ali Bader takes on nothing less than the ethnic and political history of the Middle East from 1926 – 2006 for his scope. An unnamed Iraqi writer, whose life parallels that of the author in many ways, has been asked by USA Today News to ghostwrite a 1000-word article about the murder of Kamal Medhat, an eighty-year-old Iraqi violinist whose body has recently been found. Because Baghdad is so dangerous and so risky for westerners, the speaker will do the investigatory work there, but the finished story will appear under the name of John Barr, one of USA Today’s senior correspondents, a common practice for western news media these days, the writer explains. The Press Cooperation Agency and AC Media & News group also want a full-length biography of Kamal Medhat, however, and they will pay all the speaker’s expenses and supply him with files and documents for the eventual biography which he will write under his own name. As a result of this support, the writer will stay in Baghdad’s Green Zone for a month; in Tehran where the violinist stayed on several different occasions, before going to Moscow, where the writer will also go; and in Damascus where the writer spends another two months of research. What he discovers about the murdered violinist’s life becomes the main narrative of this book.

To call this book a murder mystery, as it is called on Amazon, is like calling Joyce’s Ulysses a travel guide to Dublin. Kamal Medhat, it turns out, is one of three completely different identities and separate cultural backgrounds used by the same man, the only common thread being his virtuosic skill at the violin, and the writer is hard pressed to follow the violinist’s trail as he moves through Iraq, Iran, Syria, Russia, and even Czechoslovakia. Yousef Sami Saleh, the earliest identity, is a Jewish resident of Baghdad from 1920 – 1953, who moved to Israel and (officially) died in 1955; Haidar Salman lived in Tehran as a Shia, then returned to Baghdad in 1958, and after a coup, escaped back to Tehran before moving to Moscow; and Kamal Medhat Mustafa, an Iraqi Baathist, had to deal with the Iran-Iraq War, the rise of Saddam Hussein, the Second Gulf War (the invasion of Kuwait), and the Third Gulf War, launched by the US. All three “identities” are the same man, married anew under each identity and the father of a son by each of his three wives.

Portrait of Fernando Pessoa by Jose de Alamada Negreiros

Author Ali Bader has long been fascinated with metaphysics and views of identity, as he has previously demonstrated in his novel Papa Sartre, and he uses the violinist’s three personas, with their different personalities, in direct parallel with the three personas used by Fernando Pessoa in his poetry book The Tobacco Shop, selections of which begin the novel and echo throughout. Pessoa considered men to be of three personality types: the keeper of flocks, the persona known in the poetry book of The Tobacco Shop as Alberto Caeiro; the protected man, known as Ricardo Reis; and the tobacconist, known as Alvaro de Campos, giving the lie to any concept of an essential “identity” since all of them are part of the identity of Fernando Pessoa himself. All of the violinist’s sons, who grow up in different countries from the violinist, also parallel the identities of Pessoa’s characters in The Tobacco Shop.

The author continues the metaphysical parallels by suggesting that similarly, three different identities pervade and overlap among the Middle Eastern countries of Iraq, Iran, and Syria, with Israel providing yet another set of characteristics and identity, and that it is these competing ideas of their own national identity which are responsible for the succession of wars among these countries. Though the US is sometimes considered responsible for the Third Gulf War in Iraq, the author also suggests that by the time that war broke out, the revolutions in both Iran and Iraq and the rise of the clerics had led to a mob mentality. “Distinctions of class had disappeared and easily manipulated groups had emerged onto the scene. The mob would march and burn and destroy with a blind, random force that knew no bounds.”

The Prague Concert Hall, where Haidar Salman plays

Carefully organized thematically, the novel is unconventional in style. The first thirty pages summarize by date the history of the Middle East, especially of Iran and Iraq, with information about the various personas of the main character, where he is, and what he is doing inserted into the chronological context. Resembling a dissertation, this section creates the feeling that this is complex non-fiction, and, though necessary for understanding the book, it is challenging to a reader unfamiliar with this history.

Some confusion also results from the fact that the journalist who is the speaker is telling a story about his search for information about Kemal Medhat. He is “reporting about,” rather than bringing a character to life the way one expects in fiction. The main character’s story feels like a biography, more than fiction, though that is also related to the fact that the speaker is a journalist, accustomed to using that style.

Battle scene from the Iran-Iraq War

The journalistic style allows the author to tell about many issues and to describe a huge number of characters as the speaker discovers information about them. Of necessity, it also means that one does not “get inside” the characters. Rather, we see how they behave (or have behaved) and figure out what it all means on our own.  The author walks a fine line here among genres, since his use of parallels between the three-part main character, the three personas in Pessoa’s The Tobacco Shop, and the interconnected histories of the countries involved are needed to provide a broader, more universal thematic context than one gets in biographies. Ultimately, the author writes a novel of broad import from a unique point of view, making it understandable to the western reader despite the complexity of the historical record underlying the story. Different from the typical novel in style, this is very challenging but very rewarding to read.

ALSO by Ali Bader:  PAPA SARTRE

Photos, in order: The author’s photo is from http://www.banipal.co.uk

The portrait of Fernando Pessoa by Jose de Alamada Negreiros appears on http://expatinlisbon.com

The violinist is seen here:  http://www.focusonlinecommunities.com

The Prague Concert Hall, where Haidar Salman plays, is from http://www.dreamstime.com

The battle scene from the Iran-Iraq War:  http://www.msnbc.msn.com

ARC:  Bloomsbury Qatar

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »