Feed on
Posts
Comments

“The prizefighter is no more what the spectators imagine him to be than the lady with the wand and the star, in the pantomime, is really a fairy queen…I have never been given to close personal friendships, as you know, and Gene Tunney is among the very few for whom I have established a warm affection.  I enjoy his company as I have that of few men.”–George Bernard Shaw

Jay R. Tunney, a son of the famous prizefighter Gene Tunney (and also vice-president of the International Shaw Society), recreates the story of the twenty-year friendship between his father and George Bernard Shaw with such love, admiration, and sensitivity to the intensely intellectual relationship between these two men that the reader cannot help but be swept up by this story of two men who, ignoring a forty-year age difference, found enduring satisfaction in each other’s company:  John James (Gene) Tunney was thirty-two; Shaw was seventy-three when they met in 1929.  Both men had already achieved the peaks of their professions by that time, and they now had the leisure to explore new realms.  Tunney had retired as heavyweight champion of the world in 1928, and Shaw had won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1925.

Both men were Irish, both saw boxing as a noble sport representing Greek ideals, and both were passionately interested in serious literature.  Shaw had participated in boxing matches as a young man himself, and he followed the sport religiously, even writing a novel about a prizefighter, Cashel Byron’s Profession.   Tunney found in Shaw a mentor who treated him as an equal, listened to his ideas, and argued happily about the most erudite aspects of Shakespeare.

Tunney and Shaw met in 1929, while Tunney and his new bride, Polly Lauder Tunney, were on an extended honeymoon in Europe.  Tunney persuaded Shaw and his wife to join them while they were staying on Brioni, an island in the Adriatic where their privacy was respected, and every day for a month, Tunney and Shaw would walk and talk for hours.  Shaw has said that Tunney helped him “to plant my feet on solid ground.”  And Tunney has said, “I think of Shaw as the most considerate person I have ever known.  He was helpful, directing me aright on questions of literature, music, art, thought…No period of my life was more valuable than this.  It was like a matriculation in a cosmic school.”  When Polly, the new Mrs. Tunney, became deathly ill on Brioni, it was Shaw who spent hours there with his friend Tunney.  Tunney never believed, as others did, that Shaw was the atheist he was purported to be.

The Tunneys were an exceptionally close couple, and their courtship – the story of a serious, young Irishman from Greenwich Village, who happened to be a prizefighter, and a shy young heiress of Andrew Carnegie from Connecticut – is a beautifully revealed love story by their son.  Conducted in secret for about two years to avoid the press and to provide privacy for Mary Josephine (Polly) Lauder, the relationship became public only after Gene Tunney officially retired from the ring.  Then, two weeks later, Polly’s mother announced her engagement.  Their wedding was to be in Europe in the hopes that it would avoid the press, but, alas, that was not to be.  They were pursued as relentlessly in Europe as they had been in the US.  It was for this reason that they stayed on Brioni for a year – they had privacy there that they never had anywhere else.

Many years later, it was Mrs. Tunney who suggested to her son Jay, who wanted to write about his father, that he avoid doing a straight biography.  Those had been done in the past, and they had failed to capture Tunney’s essence, often implying that his late-in-life academicism was a pose.  She suggested that he write about the Shaw/Tunney relationship, which she had had ample opportunity to observe and to participate in.  A testament to her vision and to her son’s commitment, this book is not only important to historians, but it is also a book with a great love story and an homage to a man who became a scholar without any traditional schooling.

Brilliant, sensitive, and committed, Gene Tunney was  an autodidact who could quote reams of Shakespeare and other poets, and his eventual lectures at Yale on Shakespeare (conducted without notes) were serious scholarship, accepted by the university as such.  A friend of Billy Phelps (William Lyons Phelps, of Yale, who was an English professor there for forty-one years), Tunney also was friends with Thornton Wilder, with whom he traveled in Europe, and with Somerset Maugham, John P. Marquand, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Horace Walpole, H. G. Wells, Charlie Chaplin, Max Beerbohm, and Ernest Hemingway.

When Gene Tunney died in 1978, at the age of 81, the Boston Herald said, “Gentleman Gene left a legacy of physical and intellectual stamina that should inspire us all.  The Washington Star added, “Mr. Tunney was given to quoting Shakespeare.  He looked like an actor; he sailed to Europe to talk with George Bernard Shaw; he did not act like a pug…There was never any real understanding of this man, who was too gifted, too fast and driven, to stay where the people wanted him.”  His son Jay has corrected that.   His story of Gene Tunney will be considered the final, incisive word.  (On my Favorites List for 2010, the best non-fiction I read all year.)

Photos, in order: The photo of Jay Tunney shows him in front of a portrait of his father by Sir John Lavery, which Polly Lauder Tunney purchased on their honeymoon.  The photo is by Christopher Capozziello for the NYTimes: www.nytimes.com

The wedding photo is from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polly_Lauder_Tunner.

The photo of a smiling Tunney is by Associated Press: www.nytimes.com

THE PRIZEFIGHTER AND THE PLAYWRIGHT
Review, Biography, Book Club Suggestions, Historical, Ireland and Northern Ireland, Non-fiction, US Regional, Prizefighting, George Bernard Shaw
Written by: Jay Tunney
Published by: Firefly Books April 2, 2010
ISBN: 978-1554076413
Available in: Hardcover

“[Sao Paulo] may not be the most beautiful, or the most poetic, or the most formally perfect, but it is the biggest, the loudest, the dirtiest, the most brazen [city in the country].  Twenty million souls and rising, and there is nothing to stop it seeping across its plateau, and nothing to get in the way of its commerce.”

James Scudamore, at age thirty-four, has already achieved the kind of accolades for his first two novels that most authors only dream of.  His debut novel, The Amnesia Clinic, won the Somerset Maugham Award and was shortlisted for the Costa First Novel Award, the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize, the Dylan Thomas Prize and the Glen Dimplex Award.  Heliopolis,  his second novel, was longlisted for the Man Booker Prize for 2009.

Raised in Brazil, Japan, and the UK, Scudamore sets this novel in Sao Paulo, a city he obviously knows well, revealing his youthful enthusiasm for life, his sharp eye for injustice, and his (perhaps naive) hope for the future in a tale which follows the life of Ludo dos Santos from his childhood till about age twenty-seven.  Ludo and his mother, a cook, had been plucked from Heliopolis, the largest favela (slum) in Sao Paulo, and established permanently at the weekend farm to which Zeno “Ze” Generoso, the fabulously wealthy owner of a chain of supermarkets, his British wife Rebecca, and his daughter Melissa travel on weekends.  Eventually, Ze adopts Ludo, schools him, and makes him a part of the high life which the rest of Ze’s family takes for granted.  Their lives are so rarefied that they almost never set foot on the ground in the city–and do not have to–since they can commute to most of the places they want to go by helicopter, avoiding the danger of the streets and the threat of kidnapping.

Telling Ludo’s story through flashbacks and foreshadowings of things to come, Scudamore quickly establishes the atmosphere and the dramatic contrasts between the lives of the poor and those of the rich in a city with virtually no middle class.  In a touching and revealing scene at the opening of the novel, Ludo, in his twenties, is killing time during a traffic jam before work, exploring a neighborhood in the process of redevelopment.  A fifteen-year-old boy, a grifter, is begging for money from two women in the square.  After being rebuffed, he decides to try his act on Ludo.  “My mother is dying,” he says.  She is in hospital and he needs the taxi fare to get there to say goodbye.  When Ludo offers instead to drive him to the hospital, the boy becomes furious, turning on Ludo and saying with caustic irony, “With a change of clothes, a bad night’s sleep and some mud on your face, you’d look just like me.”

Challenged by the boy, Ludo offers him double the amount that he is able to beg successfully from another “mark.”   Frantic to gain the money, the boy becomes impatient with his ensuing lack of success and “goes for broke,” approaching a security guard with his demands.  Disaster strikes,  and Ludo is powerless to stop it.  Though he blames himself for what happens, the event is ultimately “just one more frenzied city drama in a thousand, to be forgotten and absorbed into the oozing traffic, and perhaps mentioned in passing over lunch.”

Caught between the world of the favela, which he does not remember, and the world of the rich, to which he feels he does not really belong, Ludo is unsure of his place in the world.  More sensitive than the bosses at the ad agency for which he works and infinitely more socially aware than Ze, his adoptive father, he admits that “Sometimes I want to run away from this life to which I have been promoted,” and he sees his life as a maze with ever-narrowing paths.  A crisis erupts when Ze decides to create a whole new type of supermarket chain–MaxiBudget–to appeal to the poor in the favelas, taking the food to them for the first time.  “Affordable food.  Designated food.  Official food,” not food which may have been “hanging above the butcher’s block crawling with flies for six hours.”  His stepmother Rebecca’s Foundation will help support the effort.  Ze, of course, will make a great deal of money selling to a  huge new population, an effort which Ludo believes is made primarily to “stop [the poor] from staring hungrily through the windows of our own [regular] supermarkets” rather than from any sense of improving their welfare.

At times the novel seems to approach satire, but Ludo’s voice is too resentful of the patronizing attitudes of the rich toward the poor and too upset at their lack of conscience for the novel to feel much like satire.  Ludo feels close to the poor, especially his mother, even though he himself is benefitting from the largesse of the rich and essentially ignoring the poor.  On another issue Ludo is especially conflicted.  He is in love with his step-sister Melissa.  As all these issues, both personal and social, come together, Ludo experiences a belated and almost unique coming-of-age.

Filled with vibrant life, dramatic scenes, and many revelations about individual and social responsibility, the novel does verge on melodrama in a number of places, and some coincidences are disappointingly unrealistic.  Overall, the novel has direction and a strong sense of purpose, despite the somewhat enigmatic and “thin” ending.  The author presents a vision of life in Sao Paulo over a span of fifteen years and describes, among other things, the efforts of the city and country to improve life in the favelas (an effort further described in the photo essay for which I have provided a link in the Notes).  Even as people live and die in poverty, often seeing little change and less hope, the author, Ludo’s alter-ego, refuses to accept the status quo–”Everything will be different tomorrow,” he believes.

Photos, in order: The author’s photo appears on www4.fnac.com.

The sharp contrast between rich and poor is shown in this dramatic photo from www.neogaf.com. It is important to note that the favela beside the luxury apartment house is actually relatively  “upscale,” with cars in driveways and little trash, and some might classify as a “neighborhood” and not a slum, despite the crowded buildings.

A wonderful photo essay that highlights the work of Bete Franca of the Municipality of Sao Paulo to improve infrastructure and permanently change lives for the better appears here:  http://affordablehousinginstitute.org These improvements were financed by the World Bank.

The last photo by Jess Hurd is taken in the real favela of Heliopolis in Sao Paulo.  www.reportdigital.co.uk

The author’s website with several interviews is here:  www.jamesscudamore.com

Note: Ismail Kadare became the first WINNER of the Man Booker International Prize in 2005 for his complete body of work.

“Everywhere in the world events flow noisily on the surface, while their deep currents pull silently, but nowhere is this contrast so striking as in the Balkans.  Gales sweep the mountains, lashing the tall firs and mighty oaks, and the whole peninsula appears demented.”

Shortly after a taxi leaves the Miramax Hotel in Vienna for the airport, it veers off the autobahn, somersaults into a gully, and kills the man and woman passengers, both Albanian.  The driver, seriously injured, is taken to the hospital in critical condition.  A Dutch couple witnesses the accident, as does the driver of a Euromobil truck, and both give information to the Austrian police.  The driver, when he is able to talk, tells investigators that when he looked into the rear view mirror, immediately before the accident, the couple were “trying to kiss,” a peculiar description.  The dead man, Besfort Y., was an analyst for the Council of Europe on western Balkan affairs, and he had been a “thorn in the side of Yugoslavia” before its divisions–there is suspicion that he might have been responsible for the bombing of the country.  Despite this, the accident is initially thought to be a routine traffic accident.

It is not till several months later that the European Road Safety Institute, upon receiving a copy of the accident report, regards this as an “unusual” accident.  Three months after that, the State of Serbia and Montenegro, which had had both victims under surveillance, begins to look into the accident, and their interest, in turn, sparks the interest of the Albanian Secret Service, an eventuality which makes the narrator wonder if this is a political murder after the fall of communism, or an example of residual “communist paranoia.”  Contacting members of the Albanian community abroad, the Albanian Secret Service retrieves letters, photos, airline tickets, hotel addresses, and even bills, which give a broader picture of the lives of the two victims.

At this point at the beginning of this new novel by Albanian author Ismail Kadare, the story appears to be fairly straightforward, perhaps a police procedural or the beginning of an espionage thriller, but despite the author’s almost bare-bones style, the novel quickly becomes full of confusing information and evidence.  Nothing is as simple as it seems here, and even the characters, as their lives are investigated and explored, remain mysterious and almost impervious to analysis.  We know only what they tell us about themselves and their relationship, not what the reader may be accustomed to concluding after seeing the characters in action and interaction.

If you double-click on this map, you will go to an enlargement.

The victims, who had previously been in Strasbourg, Rome, and Luxembourg, in addition to Vienna, have known each other for twelve years, and their relationship in recent months seems to have suffered a major setback.  Rovena’s letters, in particular, show her to be sometimes cheerful, and sometimes despondent. Sometimes the letters indicate that she is a call girl and he a client.  One of Besfort’s friends has indicated that Besfort believed he had “made a mistake” with a young woman, and Rovena’s friends believe that he is planning to murder her.  At other times, however, their problems appear to be related to the political situation in the Balkans.  Several mysterious phone calls received by Besfort have suggested that he has had a “quarrel with Israel,” but Rovena notes that “After Serbia was defeated, you did not seem to know what to do with yourself, and you turned on me again.”  The Serbs have been trying to prove that Besfort has bamboozled the West, especially President Clinton, Gen. Wesley Clark, and Secretary of State Madeline Albright by becoming close to them.

Statue of Mother Teresa, an ethnic Albanian

When a mysterious researcher (perhaps the metafictional author) delves into the deepest archives of the case, he discovers the files on the two victims, and eventually believes he can solve the case by rearranging its “mosaics.”  Concentrating on the last forty weeks of their relationship, he decides to reconstruct these weeks as “acts,” or “cantos, like an ancient epic.”  At this point, the novel becomes enigmatic, to say the least, and what had seemed a fairly straightforward novel involving mysteries becomes, instead, a novel in which the author’s intentions and direction themselves remain a mystery.  Besfort has dreams, which include the signing of papers on behalf of Josef Stalin, but he also has forays inside Stalin’s head, and what is dream and what is Besfort’s imagination merge.  Parallels are drawn between the behavior of Besfort and the forty-year dictatorship of Enver Hoxha of Albania, who died in 1985.  References to the conspiracies against Hoxha also abound, though their relevance to this story is obscure.

To further complicate matters, the author also refers several times to the occult and “traces of the unnatural” as the novel develops.  A gypsy fortune teller advises Rovena.  There are references to entering “the other zone” when the two lovers travel to Albania.  Time itself swirls, confounding the chronology, which provides no dates, and erotic encounters add further complexity.  Ultimately, the author’s intentions for the novel itself become as elusive as the truth about the accident.  What appears to be a straightforward investigation of an accident ranges widely into other areas and confounds fact and fiction, history and other-worldly events.  If Kadare is trying to create a “political allegory,” by drawing parallels between the action here and the history of Albania, as he has done in other novels, the nature of his parallels remain obscure, at least to me.

ALSO by Kadare:  THE FALL OF THE STONE CITY   and   THE DOLL: A PORTRAIT OF MY MOTHER

Photos, in order: The photo of the author is from http://specials.rediff.com

The map of Albania and its bordering countries is from http://geology.com

The statue of Mother Teresa, an ethnic Albanian, is by Varga Attila and is found here:  http://commons.wikimedia.org

THE ACCIDENT
REVIEW. Albania, Experimental, Historical, Literary, Mystery, Thriller, Noir, Social and Political Issues
Written by: Ismail Kadare
Published by: Grove Press
Date Published: 11/01/2011
ISBN: 978-0802145512
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

“Wealding [was] the perfect village in aspic, at the sight of which motorists applied their brakes, artists happily set up easels, cyclists dismounted and purchased picture postcards to send to their little nieces….Its perfect peace was, [however], a sham.”

In much the same way that Virginia Woolf focuses on one day in the life of Mrs. Dalloway, in the aftermath of World War I, to show the dramatic changes in everyday British life as a result of the war, author Mollie Panter-Downes shows the equally dramatic changes which have occurred in Wealding, near Portsmouth in the south of England, in 1946, in the aftermath of World War II.   Panter-Downes lived in the picturesque village of Haslemere, and she uses her own experience to create sensitive, often unique, images about everyday life in her town (which becomes Wealding).  Here she creates a vibrant portrait of ordinary people coping, or not coping, with a whole new way of life.  In lush, often musical prose, she appeals to the reader’s senses, as well as the heart, as the Marshall family–wife Laura, husband Stephen, and daughter Victoria–go about their business in a world which no longer resembles anything they have known before. The village, the author tells us, “had very slightly curdled and changed colour.”

Laura Marshall, a relaxed woman who lives every moment, has found herself with a large house and virtually no staff to help her run it.  The young women from the village, who went to the cities to work in factories during the war, prefer their lives there, and Laura has been trying unsuccessfully to care for the house herself.  Husband Stephen, a neat, conscientious, and uptight man, who had prized his roses and their carefully manicured grounds, has been away at war for seven years and has just returned to a place he hardly recognizes, a house which is “slowly giving up” and a garden so overgrown “it seems almost to bear a grudge.”   Working in London, Stephen is gone most of the day, and Laura worries that “Ulysses has returned to a Penelope grown boring, commonplace, grey.”

After Stephen goes to work and daughter Victoria goes to school, Laura begins her day, visiting people she knows, reminiscing about Philip Drayton, whom she once almost married; and visiting the Cranmers, the family which owned the largest estate in the village.  They have decided to move into a new apartment in the stable of their former house while the house is used for a holiday hotel and an agricultural training school for boys.  She remembers the sewing circles at the Cranmers’ house; visits people who have lost sons, wives, and husbands during the war; and contemplates a visit from her own impossibly demanding and aristocratic mother.  Eventually she climbs Barrow Downs on this beautiful day so she can survey the village from a height, coming to new conclusions about her own life, her family, and the new direction she will take when she returns.  Ironically, Stephen, on his way home, is also contemplating changes in his own life.

If the novel sounds as if nothing happens, that is correct as far as a “plot” is concerned, but Panter-Downes renders the little, “unimportant” events in the lives of Laura and her family so sensitively, and she reveals the feelings and the nature of real people dealing with real changes so vibrantly, that the images and characters leap off the page and stick permanently in the reader’s own memory.  Capturing the small details through which all people remember the past and, one hopes, prepare for a future, the author involves the reader completely in one ordinary day from 1946, the success of her novel a testament to the universality of her themes and the ability of human beings to adapt to changes over which they have little control.

The profound honesty and psychological realism of her characters make them “modern,” even though they “lived” over sixty years ago, and the author’s own awareness of the “world writ small” makes this novel with its unique images and descriptions one to savor.  Not just a memento of a time gone by, One Fine Day fills post-war England with living, breathing characters, as relevant to the present as they must have been sixty years ago when this novel was first published.  Virago Press has done literature an enormous service by reprinting this almost-forgotten novel by one of the great observers of post-war England.

Photos: The house in Haslemere, depicted here, which might have been similar to that of Laura Marshall, is actually a B and B:  www.haslemere.org.uk

Barrow Downs, which features in the novel’s most important scenes, is a favorite of hikers and may be found here:  www.ukholidays.org

“Did you ever imagine having to go to prison?  I mean, the way an employee imagines being fired or a doctor imagines contracting an illness?  A professional risk?  Or did you think you’d keep going and end up retiring as a terrorist, in the old terrorists’ home, where young terrorists would look after you?”–Old acquaintance, questioning a newly released terrorist.

Bernhard Schlink faces a monumental challenge in this novel in which he attempts to connect the terrorism of the Red Army Faction (represented by the Baader-Meinhof Gang in Germany in the seventies) with the earlier German national terrorism that the Nazis represented and the contemporary terrorism of Al-Qaeda.  Here he investigates what makes people become terrorists and what happens to them in the aftermath of their crimes.  At one point Schlink even has a character question whether Germany is the victim of a curse:  “Isn’t it a curse, what’s being passed on from the [World War II] generation before Jorg [a Baader-Meinhof member who killed four people] to Jorg, and from Jorg to his son?… We still have witches and fairies, and there are curses that are sometimes lifted from us only after generations.”

This tendency to avoid looking at the real issues, as illustrated by this quotation, unfortunately pervades this novel which had the potential to cast real light on terrorism and the myriad ways it affects not only society and its victims but also the terrorists who have committed crimes, including murder, in the name of improving society.

Set in the present, the novel opens with Christiane, the physician sister of Jorg, a man who has been imprisoned for twenty-four years for his crimes in the 1980s, waiting outside the prison from which he is to be released.  She has planned a weekend at the dilapidated but spacious old estate she and a friend have purchased in Brandenberg, a place surrounded by parkland and fields, with a stream and sense of quietude that everyday life does not often offer.  She has invited several of Jorg’s former friends to join them for the weekend, before the press and the country can intrude on their privacy, and she has high hopes of providing Jorg with an environment in which he can let down and begin to come to terms with his past and his long imprisonment.  Of the people who visit for the weekend, all have been supporters of the RAF movement in the past, but none, other than Jorg, have participated in the sometimes deadly actions taken by the group in the belief that they are making positive changes for the country.  Significantly, all have established new lives, and none are currently involved in any radical causes.

The action, as it evolves, is psychological action, primarily, and a sense of ominous prescience, as characters interact, is reminiscent of some of Agatha Christie’s “closed room” mysteries.  Everyone wants answers to questions, but no one is sure what to ask or how to evaluate the answers.  Jorg, the “hero” of the eighties, is a weakened man who is out of touch with present-day life, having little idea of the major changes that have occurred politically during the twenty-four years that he has been incarcerated.  As the weekend guests connect and reconnect with each other, and former loves and former relationships are recalled and sometimes rekindled, the reader is left hoping that the author will get the novel out of the personal and into the universal which will give meaning to their actions.

The author frequently reminds the reader of the continuing terrorism of Al-Qaeda (with which one guest wants to connect his current anti-government organization), and two scenes in the book are set in the World Trade Center during the September 11 attack.  One takes place at the Windows of the World Restaurant, and one takes place on a lower floor after a plane crashes into the building and sets it on fire. Considering the enormous difference in scale between the 9/11 attack and the events of from Jorg’s past, I was personally offended by the connections Schlink made between the Baader-Meinhof crimes, however terrible, with the single worst act of terrorism in world history.  Linking them seemed opportunistic, a way to draw on the horrors of 9/11 in order to add emotionalism to the impact of the novel.

The novel could have been a thorough and thoughtful analysis of Germany between World War II and the present, with an even more thorough analysis of the philosophical and political issues also involved.  Between the passage in which a character blames the problems of German terrorism on some mystical curse and the author’s later attempts to link the attacks on the World Trade Center to the historical issues in Germany between the Nazis and the present, however, I found that I lost my interest in these characters and their fictional problems.  Schlink is a talented writer with a unique gift for conveying descriptions, especially lyrical ones, but this novel, which promised so much, was ultimately a disappointment.

Photos, in order: The author’s photo is from www.moviepilot.de

The photo of the old house in Brandenburg, surrounded by a park-like setting, is from http://img175.imageshack.us

The Wanted poster for the Baader-Meinhof Gang is from http://germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org.

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »