Feed on
Posts
Comments

Ioanna Karystiani–SWELL

Note:  This novel was WINNER of the National Award for Best Greek Novel of 2007.

“An Avgoustis does not die on dry land, and [Mitsos Avgoustis], in particular, would never take part in that old age which slowly and wordlessly undulates from one train stop to the next, from the left side of the sidewalk to the opposite, from the morning bench of this square to the afternoon bench of that one.”

Dimitrios Avgoustis, now seventy-five, has been a seaman in the Greek merchant marine for 58 years, a captain for much of that time, well respected by his crew.  He is less respected by his family, however, especially by his less than steadfast wife Flora, an embittered, angry woman who was going to separate from him before she became pregnant with their son Andonis, twenty-two years ago.  Dimitrios, known to various acquaintances as Mitsos or Mimi, has not seen his family for years, has two daughters who hate him, a five-year-old granddaughter he has never seen, and a twenty-two year-old son who desperately wants a father but has never known him.  Mitsos has not written a letter home or looked at any photographs of his family in years.  “I love my family but from a distance of ten thousand miles,” he says, and for the last ten years, he has remained rooted to his ship, not even going ashore when the ship lands in port.

Telling Avgoustis’s story obliquely from several points of view, including that of Litsa, the true love of his life, whom he has also abandoned in Greece, author Ioanna Karystiani creates a tender portrait of a proud man in thrall to the “swell,” with little to draw him home.  It is only when the reader discovers (early in the novel) that Mitsos is actually blind, something that he has been able to keep secret from everyone, including his crew, that some of his deliberate self-isolation begins to make sense.  He knows every foot of his ship, the Athos III, eats every meal alone in his cabin, stares at maps “from memory,” grows a beard so he will not need to shave, and lets his hair grow to shoulder length.  He runs the ship by feel, through the “swell,” even bringing the ship safely through bad storms and equipment failures.  As long as he does not return to Greece or be available to meet company representatives, they cannot force him to give up his ship.

Mitsos believes he is safe in his job, despite his blindness and his age, because he once saved the life of the Athos III’s owner, a man who wrote into his will that Mitsos would serve as long as Mitsos himself saw fit, and that when he finally did retire, he would receive one hundred thousand pounds promised, cash in hand, from the owner.  The owner, however, has just died, at age 88, and his son, who has only made one trip to sea in his life, is anxious to get rid of Mitsos:  He can replace the crew with Asians who will work for lower wages.  When Mitsos’s wife Flora is enlisted by the owner’s heir to talk Mitsos into retiring, she meets the ship and quickly discovers his real problem.  She knows she must get him to retire on his own and return to port in Pireas, in order to get the one hundred thousand pounds.  Though Flora leaves the ship, she sees to it that she has her own representative on board to help Mitsos make the “right” decision.

In the course of the novel, the author successfully creates strong feelings for Mitsos, however selfish he may have been, but these feelings for the main character develop slowly.  Because the novel is impressionistic, the reader must fill in a great many blanks and make many connections with little help from the author before reaching a level of identification with Mitsos.  Whole sections of the novel, printed in a different type, are the voice of someone who is not completely identified till fairly late, and it can sometimes be a bit frustrating reading these thoughts without knowing for sure whose they are.  Are they by his lover?  His wife?  His hairdresser?  Names and the people to whom they refer are not always clear (many have unfamiliar nicknames), and some dialogue is difficult to follow because the names of the speakers are only rarely included with their comments. (At one point, I wondered who “Elefsina” was, since Mitsos mentions returning to her, only to discover that it is a place.)  The author does present all the necessary information during the novel but leaves it up to the reader to process it, without the usual transitions.

For the patient reader, however, Mitsos becomes an unforgettable character, proud and much more complex, emotionally, than he seems at first to be.  Somehow he has achieved the absolute loyalty of his crew, which never questions his actions and never suspects his blindness:  “Having served under Avgoustis was tantamount to two or three Harvard degrees.”  The people he has hurt most seem willing to forgive him, proving that “No one ever falls by the wayside, justice keeps slowly burning out of sight, and works itself out, all in good time.”  This challenging novel rewards careful reading–and re-reading–and gives dramatic proof that for people like Mitsos Avgoustis, “The swell was everything.”

Notes:    The author’s photo by Mike Kuder appears on the site of the International Literature Festival in Berlin where Ioanna Karystiani was guest speaker in September, 2010.  An excellent biography is also included:  www.literaturfestival.com

The Athos I, which may resemble the Athos III, is seen here:  www.ceoe.udel.edu

The port of Pireas is shown here:  http://www.onlinegreekferries.com

 

Note: Orhan Pamuk was WINNER of the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2006.

“It seemed to me now that I was going to be able to enjoy…good fortune–partaking of all the pleasures of a happy home life with a beautiful, sensible, well-educated woman, and at the same time enjoying the pleasures of an alluring and wild young girl…”

Turkish author Orhan Pamuk’s latest novel soars to new heights, taking fiction itself to an exhilarating new level and blurring the lines between fiction and reality in new ways.  Ostensibly the obsessive love story of Kemal Basmaci, age thirty, for a beautiful shop-girl named Fusun, eighteen, the novel explores much more than that, examining not only the physical passion which underlies their relationship and their lives, but  also broader themes involving the connections between love and memory, between memory and reality, and between love and reality.

Including metafictional elements in the telling of Kemal’s story, Pamuk himself participates in the story as both a fictional and a real character, adding another level to the story.  In a unique tour de force, the author is now creating a (real) Museum of Innocence in Istanbul, located in the house in which Fusun and her fictional family “lived.”  In essence, we have author Pamuk creating a fictional story about fictional people, whose real house and the objects in it (described fully in the fictional story) become a real physical memorial to the fictional characters in the love story which Kemal has “asked” Pamuk to write for him.  In creating a real-life memorial to the lives of fictional characters, then, Pamuk is ultimately freeing the reader’s imagination from the constraints of fiction–giving “reality” greater meaning by allowing fiction to be part of it.  The reader’s memories of the novel’s characters will endow the museum with life as visitors discover items which have been important in the story.  The museum, in turn, will make the words on paper become the “real” people who have used these real objects.

House on Cucurcuma Cd., where the Museum of innocence is being built.

However multilayered the novel may be, it is also playful and great fun to read, as Pamuk effortlessly involves the reader in the story, which opens in 1975.  Thirty-year-old Kemal, from a wealthy family, is busy getting ready for his lavish engagement party to Sibel, an equally prominent young woman of his own “class” and someone he truly loves.  When he meets Fusun a shop-girl to whom he is passionately attracted, and who is also passionately attracted to him, he acts the way his father and uncles have always behaved in the past–he believes that he can marry Sibel and lead a social life among other people of his “class,” while still having an active private life with Fusun, a girl of a different “class” that he cannot live without.  Pamuk clearly depicts the sexual mores of Istanbul in 1975, and emphasizes the differences from western life from the same era.

The ensuing action of the novel takes place over the next thirty-one years (The plot details mentioned here are at the very beginning of the book and do not constitute spoilers.)  Kemal, weak, “entitled,” and selfish, cannot prevent his engagement to Sibel from being announced–Sibel would be an outcast if he chose to follow his heart for Fusun–and he is devastated when Fusun shows up at the engagement party with her family.  What Kemal never expects, however, considering the depth of Fusun’s love for him, is that she will then vanish, not just from his life but, seemingly from all the neighborhoods in which she has lived.  Absolutely obsessed with her, Kemal begins to exhibit signs of severe emotional problems as the wedding gets closer, and he and Sibel go off to a secluded, private “yali,” a beach house on the water, where they live for months trying to rekindle the love that they once had.

Kemal continues to live out his obsession by befriending Fusun’s parents, becoming increasingly isolated from his “real” life as a wealthy businessman, and collecting every object, including 4213 cigarette butts, which Fusun has ever touched.  His kleptomania at her parents’ house becomes worse as time progresses, and he soon has the beginnings of a museum to Fusun in an apartment that his mother uses for storage.  He also becomes involved in movie production, another level of Pamuk’s exploration of fiction vs. reality, and though this section might have benefited from judicious pruning, it does add to the thematic development and effectively suggests elements similar to those in Plato’s Allegory of the Cave.

Birds which Pamuk is painting for display in the museum. See quotation from NYTimes in Photo notes below.

What gives the book its final power is the re-appearance of Orhan Pamuk as a character in the novel’s conclusion, as he explains his relationship with Kemal (he insists in interviews that he is not Kemal) and his decision to start a real Museum of Innocence in Fusun’s family house.  This decision gives this novel a level of reality which is unique in fiction, one which I found thrilling to contemplate.  Compelling to read, filled with unusual characters, and structured to achieve the maximum possible thematic effect, The Museum of Innocence is a breath-taking novel, the best I’ve read by Pamuk, and one he will have a hard time bettering.

ALSO by Pamuk:  SNOW

Photos, in order: The author’s photo appears on his Wiki page: http://en.wikipedia.org

The narrow house on the corner of Cucurcuma Cd, the location of Fusun’s home and the site of the future Museum of Innocence, which the author plans to open in the fall of 2010, is shown here: http://jb-passages.blogspot.com

The photo of the tricycle which once belonged to Kemal and was given to distant cousin Fusun is by Olaf Becker for an article in the NYTimes Magazine: www.nytimes.com

According to Pamuk in the New York Times: Fusun, the character with whom I strove to identify in this novel, passes time in her marriage by making paintings of birds. As it happens, I was a painter in my youth. In my museum, I will show the popular birds of Istanbul, which Fusun fastidiously paints one by one, but I will paint them myself. This is a stuffed seagull and crow I have in my office that help me as I prepare the paintings for the museum. Once in a while other crows come to my balcony to peer in at this one. http://www.nytimes.comslideshow_5.html

“The Maltese had not wanted this war;  it had been called down upon their heads.  And their almost childlike faith in the ability of the British to defend them, to ultimately prevail against the forces of evil, had been tested to its limits by the gathering hell of the past few months.  After two long years of siege, they knew the truth about their predicament.”

Major Max Chadwick is the Information Officer for the British army on Malta during World War II.  “Loyal Little Malta,” a British colony strategically located between Sicily and North Africa, has been bombarded non-stop by the Germans and Italians for many months.  Though British submarines based on Malta have been interrupting German shipping in the Mediterranean since the war began, the British are almost helpless against the Axis air power.  In April, 1941, “the Luftwaffe flew a staggering 9600 sorties against the island, almost double the number for March, which itself had shattered all previous records.”   The British have three hardy biplanes–Faith, Hope, and Charity–which have been in the air around the clock in an effort to delude the Italians and Germans into thinking they have more planes than they really do.  Virtually all their Spitfires and Hurricanes have been destroyed, many while still parked at the airport, and new planes have not arrived.  The total number of aircraft available to defend Malta, at this point, is a mere ten, including Faith, Hope, and Charity, while masses of Junker 88s “with a covering fighter force of sixty” attack one or more times a day, bombing the island into rubble.

While Max tries to keep up the wartime morale of the island with his posts, the raids continue, but so does the social life for the British, with dinners, the Malta Amateur Dramatic Club, a bar scene, and, of course, the “sherry queens” who entertain at the bars.  When Carmela Cassari, a sherry queen from the Blue Parrot turns up dead, Max’s best friend, Dr. Freddie Lambert, secretly brings Max to the mortuary to see her suspicious wounds–and something else.  This time the victim is clutching a torn shoulder tab from a British uniform.  Max also learns from Freddie that two other sherry queens have also died recently. They conclude that a serial killer is on the loose, and that this killer is a British officer.

With the never-ending air raids, the constant need to rush to the shelters dug deep into Malta’s rock, the siege and its attendant shortages, and the growing number of civilian deaths, the populace is weary, and some Maltese are wondering aloud whether the British will soon abandon them to their fate.  British submarines are about to be relocated away from Malta, and the promised Spitfires have not yet arrived.  With all this bad news to deal with, Max is not sure how to deal with the three murders, which so far have not been connected in the public mind to a serial killer.   He believes that justice must be done, but fears creating an even worse morale problem on the island.  Knowing that his reports to his superiors will be ignored, he decides to investigate on his own, using some of his own contacts for information. Who to trust is a problem, however, since someone on the island with high-level knowledge (perhaps a British officer) is funneling strategic information to the Germans.

Author Mark Mills creates an atmospheric and ambitious novel of Malta, which, during World War II, was “the most bombed place on earth,” and he attempts a wide scope in less than three hundred pages.  Unfortunately, this allows him little opportunity for full development of any of his plot lines.  Though the novel takes place during a horrendous period of carpet bombing, it is not a war novel in the traditional sense, as the strategizing and maneuvering which one sees in most war novels are not significant here.  How the Maltese survived, and the inbred traits which kept driving them would have been a vibrant topic for discussion and illustration in this novel, but nearly all the important characters here are British (with one American), the Maltese remaining on the periphery.  A section which appears at the end of each chapter takes us into the mind of the killer of the sherry queens, suggesting a psychological emphasis, but the killer’s personality does not jell, and the reader does not get a sense of his compulsion to kill and why.  When the killer’s identity is learned, it comes as a surprise, rather than from a growing awareness of clues.  The three women who are killed and details of their deaths are presented as facts, rather than as stories within stories.

Still, for those interested in reading an unusual novel about “this little lump of rock in the middle of the Mediterranean” and its amazing survival during the horrors of World War II,  this novel opens up many avenues for further exploration.  The references to real places and events are numerous (and fun to look up on Google) and a sense of what the island looks like shines through. Several World War II websites devote many pages and dozens of photographs to the Siege of Malta, and through them, I became caught up in Malta’s history.  Several wonderful YouTube films bring this history to life.  (See Notes)  Though the novel has its weaknesses, it still made me want to know more about the island, and the easy internet research satisfied my curiosity.

Notes: The author’s photo appears on his Harper Collins Author Page.

The listing of available planes at the air field in Malta in 1940 shows Faith and Hope, the biplanes, still serviceable.  The next photo shows the destruction of Hopehttp://www.killifish.force9.co.uk

A rare color film shows the Battle for Malta.  Wait for the voice on this one, as the video provides much information.

Mahmoud Saeed–SADDAM CITY

“I felt the heat of my fever.  I was bleeding and crying at once.  The kicks continued to rain on me where I was lying, [my arms handcuffed behind my back]….As soon as I was up, another kick brought me down on my face…I tried to stand, but failed.  One of the torturers helped me up this time.  He then attached my handcuffs to something and I felt a pull.  Soon I was suspended from the ceiling.  I screamed inside my hood with all of my might.”

Iraqi schoolteacher Mustafa Ali Noman has spent his life avoiding Saddam Hussein’s military, the Baath Party, and controversy in general.  Happily married and the father of a young son and daughter, he and his wife are, for the first time, in a position to build a house, which he inspects  on weekends, now that the house is close to completion.  After leaving school for an hour to pay the final bill to the contractor, Noman returns to his class, but he is arrested by two Security officials as soon as he returns, taken to prison for interrogation, and slapped around:

—Mustafa Ali Othman?

I shook my head.

—No, my name is Mustafa Ali Noman.

—Makes no difference….You deny using an assumed name? Your name is Mustafa Ali Othman.

—But that’s an error.  As I’ve said, my name is Mustafa Ali Noman.

—Take him out of here.

It is 1979, and Noman knows that “sooner or later, everyone is liable to run afoul of the regime or be mistaken for someone who has.  Being free only means one thing:  imminent arrest.”  Though he is completely innocent, Noman spends the next year being moved from prison to prison, where he and those with him are tortured by some of the most painful methods ever devised.  As Noman moves around the country, he observes that ninety-nine percent of those arrested, tortured, or executed are completely innocent, yet none can prove their innocence since all are assumed to be liars from the outset.  The best any innocent person can hope for is a lighter sentence, and lighter abuse, until his eventual release, weeks, months, or years hence–if he survives prison at all.  As one of eighteen men in a cell measuring six by eight feet, Noman asserts that “despite the exhaustion, restraints, and reduction of my humanity to the banality of a mere number, I found myself in a space suffused with human warmth.  These men might have violated the laws of society or they might have been criminals from the point of view of the state, but I believed in their innocence partly because I knew my own and partly because they received me with open arms; I felt I was one of them.”

Saddam’s regime arrests anyone who whispers anything derogatory about the regime, even in the “privacy” of his own home; or who makes even a simple joke;  or who has not joined the Baath party, one responsibility of which is to report on members of the family or friends on a weekly basis.  Children are forced to tell stories about family members, and Noman is in jail with a young child, still hugging his blanket, and his uncle.  The child had been forced to betray the innocent uncle after Security killed one of the child’s acquaintances before his very eyes and threatened to torture the child to death.  Both are scheduled to be executed.   A young teenager who happened not to be carrying his birth certificate or draft card, is one of many who have been arrested, tortured, and raped.  Women, young children, and the elderly meet the same fate.  Even the loss of a license plate is enough to be arrested and held for unlimited periods of time.  People of Iranian descent are particularly vulnerable since the war between Iran and Iraq is looming, and many have registered as Iranian as a way to save their sons from the Iraqi draft.  The fact that they are usually Shias while Saddam is Sunni makes them additionally suspect.

Told in an almost journalistic style, author Mahmoud Saeed, who himself was arrested and jailed for a year in 1963 and rearrested five more times after that–up to 1980–uses his personal observations and his own feelings to pay witness to the horrors of Saddam Hussein’s regime.  His concise and straightforward style allows the reader to develop an emotional connection with the characters on his/her own, and sets Saeed’s feelings, noticeable throughout, into sharp relief.  By having Noman, a Basra resident, transferred from southern Iraq to prisons as far north as Irbil and Sulaymaniah, where five thousand Kurds suffered genocide, the author can show that the horrors and war crimes are widespread.  In some ways, reading this novel feels like reading Kafka, but the absurdities faced by Gregor Samsa and Josef K are frivolous compared to what Saddam Hossein forced upon his people.  War crimes take on a whole new meaning as “Noman” becomes an Everyman, suffering unjustly.

ALSO by Mahmoud Saeed:  THE WORLD THROUGH THE EYES OF ANGELS

Photos, in order: The author’s photo appears with a brief bio on www.sundaysalon.com , a news site from New York, Nairobi, and Chicago.

The photo of the prison at Sulaymaniah, where Noman was held at one point, shows the last of Saddam’s war materiel outside.  The photo is by Bob Keith and appears on http://gazettextra.com, which also shows additional photos of  Iraq. This is the prison in which 5000 Kurds and others were executed.

In a touching–even miraculous–development, this prison has now been converted into a memorial to the Kurds and those others executed there by Saddam Hussein.  The final photo, also by Bob Keith, shows its marvelous transformation.  The front entrance to the prison, once all concrete and brutal efficiency, now contains intricate, carved glass panels which project out from the walls and ceiling, with tiny lights illuminating the glass.  Each of these tiny lights is supposed to memorialize one of the people executed in this prison.  http://gazettextra.com Some of the cells have remained exactly as they were left so that no one ever forgets.

“I am lost, adrift, stumbling through a world I do not understand.  I hear a rustle in the undergrowth and can’t decide if it’s a jaguar stalking with ominous restraint or an LBJ scratching for worms.  I find succulent globes of fruit but don’t dare touch them for fear of poison…. I am as stupid as a child.”

Jenny Dunfree gets her first hint of some of the difficulties she will face during an ornithological research project in the San Blas Islands, off the coast of Panama, when the ticket agent at the airport refuses to sell her a one-way ticket.  Insisting that she does not want to return the following day, Jenny is unable to convince anyone at the airport that she will stay on Sugatupu for an extended period of time.  Her duties, funded by a foundation, are to study a nest of harpy eagles, a rare species, and keep notes on their behavior, their feeding habits, and any eaglets which may appear.  Exhausted when she finally makes her way to Sugatupu by canoe, she is immediately accosted by a young boy who drags her through the night-time forest to the village meeting house. There, she must list her genealogy for the village elders.  She is not allowed to tell her own name, however, nor is anyone else allowed to ask it.  “Without a name, do I have a soul?  Am I a real person?” she wonders.

Jenny is expected to appear at the village meeting house every Saturday evening, without fail, though she does not speak the Kuna language of her Indian hosts, and most of them speak little or no Spanish.  Living as isolated as possible from the rest of Panama, the Kuna Indians have their own culture, thousands of years old, and the biggest influences (and some of their biggest problems) have come from missionaries who have wanted to change their beliefs about the world, impose a new system of morality, redefine the nature of good and evil, and educate the Kuna children in missionary schools away from the island.  They love nature and believe in a spirit world which includes all animals, plants, and even rocks, and they understandably resent the intrusions of those who would change their ways of life.

Because Jenny obviously appreciates nature, which is the basis of all the Kuna beliefs, she is watched over and somewhat protected by the Kuna.   San Blas has also been recognized as a dropping point for cocaine, and Jenny has become friends with a white man who sometimes shows up to chat with her, armed with a pistol.  As her research work continues, she becomes more and more convinced that the eagles that she is observing are not harpy eagles at all, a fact that could jeopardize the whole project.

Author Louise Young, herself an ecologist who began working in the San Blas islands in 1996, had intended this book to be a National Geographic-style travel piece in which she used the  voice of an “armchair anthropologist,” but she says she eventually found that a fictionalized anthropological framework worked better.  “Fiction became my tool to muscle stick-figure stereotypes into the array of personalities that inhabit all human communities,” she says.  Her characters are, in fact, often stereotypes, but she succeeds in creating a broad picture of the Kuna culture she is depicting because the culture itself is so interesting.

It is twenty-five-year-old Jenny who is the most annoying stereotype, a woman with an advanced degree who is depicted, primarily, as a woman, and only secondarily as an ecologist, anthropologist, and scientist.  Jenny has romantic and unrealistic visions of her role at the outset, and she appears to be sexually attracted  (quite often) to a number of the village men, disregarding any sense of detachment about her supposed role.  She cries a lot, frequently uses the kind of profanity common among young college students, smokes dope when she has the opportunity, and is “saved” on a regular basis by the men who feel the need to protect her.

The novel becomes deeper as it progresses, and the reader’s fascination with the culture grows.  Ultimately, it is Jenny’s respect for the culture and beliefs which make the novel work.  Though it is clear that some aspects of the culture of these islands will inevitably change, the author’s own work there as a “cultural guide” and “technical advisor to a women’s cooperative” will help preserve the essence of their way of life.

Notes: The author’s photo appears on her Amazon Author page.

The map of Panama, showing the San Blas Islands on the Atlantic coast, is from:  www.tropicaldiscovery.com

The women of the San Blas Islands are famous for making molas, elaborate cutwork of abstract designs from nature, which they use on the front and back of their blouses.  The lobster mola, shown here, is from the Museum of Quilts and Textiles in San Jose.  Molas are made by piling up individual layers of colored cloth, in this case at least nine different layers:  Working with only a razor blade or a small pair of scissors and a needle and thread, [the maker cuts through layers until she reaches the color  she wants, and then hems around it], creating some of the most intricate stitchery found anywhere on earth. www.turq.com

Author Louise Young, whose own quilt work is in museums, gives tours to the these islands.  www.molatour.com Her blog is here: www.redroom.com.

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »