Feed on
Posts
Comments

“I don’t think I’m singing.  I feel like I am playing a horn.  I try to improvise like Les Young, like Louis Armstrong or someone else I admire.  What comes out is what I feel.  I hate straight singing.  I have to change a tune to my own way of doing it.  That’s all I know.” Billie Holiday, Nov. 1, 1939

41r-Q+Im6nL._SX331_BO1,204,203,200_In Melville House Publishing’s Last Interview series, Billie Holiday’s own words define her and reflect her difficult life through eight interviews.  The first is given on November 1, 1939, published in Downbeat Magazine, and the last is twenty years later, published in October, 1959, in Confidential Magazine, an interview she granted two days before her death in a New York hospital at age forty-four.  Born in Philadelphia on April 7, 1915, her life was hard lived, and when she died, a victim of her addictions to drugs and alcohol, she was depressed about her life and the fact that she might be forgotten.  Her fans, she believes, “forget the laughter and the weeping I brought to people who waited for a voice to sing the happy and the crying songs they wanted so much to hear.  They don’t remember the woman – they just remember the wreck.  That’s how people are – they remember someone else’s misery to forget their own.”

Young Billie with her dog, Mister. Photo by Rex Shutterstock.

Young Billie with her dog, Mister. Photo by Rex Shutterstock.

Born in Philadelphia, she grew up in Baltimore, the daughter of Clarence Holiday of the Fletcher Henderson Orchestra, with whom she had little contact after the age of ten.  According to Khanya Mtshali, who wrote the substantial Introduction to this book, Billie was raped at around age ten and sent to a Catholic reformatory school for about two years, but was released “with the help of relatives” and later moved to New York with her mother, “where they began engaging in sex work to make ends met.  Holiday was only fourteen.”  In the the book’s first interview by Dave Dexter, with Downbeat Magazine on Nov. 1, 1939, she talks about those early years when she and her mother “were so hungry we could barely breathe.” Desperate, she began walking down Seventh Avenue one day, stopping at every “joint” looking for work.  Eventually, she got her chance, and when the pianist, Dick Wilson, played “Body and Soul,” she soared:  “Jeez, you should have seen those people – all of them started crying….[and] that’s how I got my start.”  By fifteen, she had recorded a side with Benny Goodman, with Gene Krupa in the band.

Billie leaving the police station after her arrest in 1956.

Billie leaving the police station after her arrest in 1956.

Eight years later, in another Downbeat Magazine Interview by Michael Levin on June 4, 1947, Billie has just been released on $1000 bail after her first big arrest for drugs.  By that time, according to Wikipedia, she was at her commercial peak, having earned $250,000 in the previous three years.  In the Michael Levin Interview, she blames no one but herself for her problems:  “Whatever I did wrong, nobody else but me was to blame…I’m not offering an alibi, I’m not singing the blues,” but she then goes on to offer the fact that “my mother died 18 months ago, the only relative I had in the world. I guess I flipped, ran through more than $100,000 since then.  But I was trying to go straight.  It just seems as though I have a jinx over me.”  Though she has already “taken the cure” for three weeks, at a cost of $3000, “Now the federal people tell me they may send me away for another cure…Just when things were going to be so big and I was trying so hard to straighten myself out.  Funny, isn’t it?”

Billie with her friend and neighbor, Ella Fitzgerald.

Billie with Louis Armstrong, with whom she worked on a film.

Between the first interview in November, 1939, and the second interview, in June, 1947, Billie Holiday recorded her most famous songs: “Strange Fruit,” about lynchings in the South, in 1939;  “God Bless the Child,” in 1941, a song which eventually sold over a million copies; “Don’t Explain,” in 1944;  “What is This Thing Called Love,” in 1944; and “Good Morning, Heartache,” in 1946.  She worked in a major film in September, 1946, with Louis Armstrong and Woody Herman.  Unfortunately, her drug problems, according to Wikipedia, were a problem on the set of the film and though she earned over a thousand dollars a week from her club work, “she spent most of it on heroin.”  In the 1947 Michael Levin Interview in Downbeat, however, she insists, “I just want to be straight with people, not have their sympathy. And remember, nobody else in show business has made as many mistakes as me.”

Billie with her friend and neighbor, Ella Fitzgerald.

Billie with her friend and neighbor, Ella Fitzgerald.

By 1952, in her August 16 Interview with Dick Macdougall, she is reminiscing about the “good old days,” including her inspiration from Bessie Smith, who was one of her mother’s friends, and her friendships with with Louis Armstrong, Billy Eckstine, Benny Goodman, Mildred Bailey, Teddy Wilson, Count Basie, and Ella Fitzgerald – her neighbor in New York.  By now she has traveled all over the world, but she is not happy about the state of music in 1952.  “All the artists are doing are bringing back all the old tunes….There’s really nothing happening….The things that I sing have to have something to do with me and my life, and my friends’ lives, and…it has to have a meaning, you know?  The things they’re writing today, nothing’s happening.”

Grave of Billie Holiday and her mother in the Bronx, New York.

Grave of Billie Holiday and her mother in the Bronx, New York.

The “Lost Billie Holiday Interview” with George Walsh of KNX Radio Los Angeles, from September 1956, was “unheard for nearly sixty years, until…it was resurrected by Gordon Skene…in 2015” and republished here.  Holiday’s manner of speaking in this interview suggested she was “under the influence” and management decided not to air it.  Her January, 1959, Statement in the Office of the Supervising Custom Agent, United States Treasury Department, is included here.  She had failed to declare to Customs upon entering the country from a stay in Paris and Italy that she had been convicted of narcotics offenses and had served  a year and a day at the Federal Reformatory for Women in Alderson, West Virginia.  She was unfamiliar with this new regulation and had not seen the notice posted at the airport.  Her Final Interview takes place two days before she died on July 17, 1959, and is (surprisingly) attributed to Billie Holiday herself.  Dying alone, with a policewoman in her room because a nurse claimed she had bits of heroin on her face, Holiday admits to having been a heroin addict for fifteen years.  Ultimately, she says,“I hold no regrets and I carry no shame…If my life was wrong or right – good or bad – it’s still my life and what’s about to happen – will happen just to me….[And] when I leave this lump they call the world, I’m going to leave all my blues behind and walk off singing.”  Billie Holiday has truly lived her song, “Don’t Explain.”

Billie Holiday sings “Strange Fruit,” 1959, the year of her death:

Photos:  Young Billie Holiday with her dog, Mister.  Photo by Rex Shutterstock.  https://www.thetimes.co.uk

Billie leaving the police station after her arrest in 1956.  https://www.biography.com

Billie with Louis Armstrong, with whom she worked on a film.  https://www.biography.com/

Billie with Ella Fitzgerald, her neighbor.  https://www.wtju.net

Grave of Billie Holiday with her mother in the Bronx, New York.  https://www.pinterest.com

BILLIE HOLIDAY: THE LAST INTERVIEW and OTHER CONVERSATIONS
REVIEW. VIDEO. PHOTOS. Autobiography/Memoir, Historical, Psychological study, Social Issues, US , Jazz
Written by: Billie Holiday and Khanya Mtshali
Published by: Melville House
Date Published: 07/30/2019
ISBN: 978-1612196749
Available in: Ebook Paperback

Jo Nesbo–KNIFE

“The old man could see it now. A beam of light coming from upriver, off to the right…[He] opened his mouth when he saw the spaceship come into the picture.  It was lit up from within and was hovering a meter and a half off the riverbed.  The current knocked it against a large rock, and almost in slow motion, it spun round until the light from the front of it swept across the riverbed and for a moment blinded the old man when it hit the camera lens…It was a car…full of water almost up to the roof.  There was someone in there.” – from the opening chapter.

cover knifeNorwegian author Jo Nesbo, regarded by many as the best thriller writer of the century, always plunges directly into his stories, with vivid opening images like the one quoted above, in which characters raise questions about darkly surprising events that appear without warning, often during emergencies. The reader, too, has questions about the who, what, when, and why of these very early events which raise the suspense from the start, and, in turn, lead the reader to speed ahead, looking for answers to conundrums which may not be truly resolved until much later in the novel.  Nesbo’s descriptive talents are legion, enough to seduce even the most jaded reader into becoming involved in these novels from the outset.  From mysterious events like the one quoted above, in which a character sees something that he cannot believe, to moments in which someone experiences violence, fends off an attack, recognizes that the truth is different from what he has always believed, or fears for a loved-one’s safety, Nesbo is in total control, with most readers hanging on for the wild ride sure to follow.

author photo stia brochHarry Hole, the main character of Knife (and of the series bearing his name), has long been known for his alcoholism, blackouts, and complete lack of control, which he continues to exhibit in his self-destructive rages against the world at large.  While I am tired of Harry’s negative behavior after reading all twelve novels in the Harry Hole series, this new offering, Knife, is so well written that it has made me regard Nesbo’s work in a new light.  The best of the best, it has beautifully developed themes, flawless pacing,  intriguing and repeating subordinate characters, imaginative plotting, unrelenting dark atmosphere, and unexpected twists – one after another – after another – the likes of which I have never seen any other author even come close to duplicating.  Most excitingly, Nesbo keeps all levels of his themes on point throughout the action, while adding a whole new level of development.  His objective goes beyond the obvious goal of having Harry Hole win in his battle against crime by catching the murderer or murderers whom the police are seeking.  Now Harry Hole wants true justice – which in this case means seeing that a guilty person gets punished to the degree that he truly deserves – and Harry Hole is the one who decides what that amount will be.

Jo Nesbo is a professional musician in addition to an author, and he includes many references to groups and singers especially the Ramones, in this novel.

Jo Nesbo, a professional musician in addition to an author, includes many references to groups and singers, especially the Ramones, in this novel.

If he knows for sure that a murderer is dead, for example, that man obviously cannot be punished for the murder he committed, and the murder remains unavenged.  But if a confessed murderer, or serial killer, remains at large, unpunished, simply because there is not enough hard evidence to convict him, Harry sees no problem with stacking up some new evidence that might tie that killer to an unavenged murder he did not commit so that he can then be convicted as he deserves to be.  In the grand scheme of things, Harry regards this as judicially fair – after all, murder is murder, and in his mind it makes no difference which murder sends a killer to jail.  In an interesting reverse of this, which also occurs in Knife,  a father takes the blame for a murder committed by one of his adult children, even signing a confession, but after Harry investigates why, he refuses to let the adult child who committed the crime go free.   With a complex plot, more than one murder, a serial killer on the loose, and a series of repeating characters with past histories related to Harry Hole, Knife offers non-stop drama and action.

Lader Sagens Gate, is not a gate at all. It is a building, now used as a music school, and a landmark in Oslo. Harry and Jborn discuss the murderer here.

Lyder Sagens Gate, is not a gate at all. It is a building, now used as a music school, and a landmark in Oslo. Harry and BJorn discuss the murderer here.

I have deliberately avoided saying much about the plot here because it is a doozy, filled with emotion and surprises, and I do not want to spoil it for the reader.  It is enough to say that the main event occurs when someone well known to Harry is murdered.  The major suspect, Svein Finne, a sexual predator, has just been released from prison after serving twenty years.  While he was in prison, his son, Valentin Gjertsen, “one of the worst killers in Norwegian criminal history,” was killed by Harry Hole, and Finne now wants revenge.  Harry believes that the killing of his friend was a revenge killing by Finne, and when the two confront each other in an abandoned bunker, Harry beats Finne brutally.  Not long after, however, another person, Roar Bohr, is thought more likely to be the killer.  And he is not the only new suspect.  Harry has been drinking to the point of unconsciousness, and when he is found with blood on his clothes and hands, one member of the police suggests that Harry himself may have been the murderer.  Harry remembers nothing.

Smestaddammen

A murder takes place late in the novel at Smestaddammen on the side of the lake. The victim had been shot from across the lake.

Suspended from the police department,  he works on his own to try to solve the murder, relying, occasionally, on some of his police friends, familiar to Nesbo fans, who are actively involved in the investigation.  Through flashbacks and flashforwards, the investigation proceeds. Subplots galore keep the action going, and close-up scenes with the debilitated Harry make his own erratic behavior increasingly suspect. Supporting characters deal with additional crimes, and various characters of both sexes find each other for romance – with several of the women “adopting” Harry.   Several characters show sides of themselves that come as surprises to the reader – and to Harry – and that adds to the excitement and the mystery.  The action is constant and well developed, and as each complication arises, the reader sees how Jo Nesbo is developing his theories of justice, what it really means, and how it should be applied.   Nesbo’s genius and his care for details make this Nesbo’s most thrilling thriller to date.

Rakel compares her love and Harry Hole's to the root system of the oldest tree in the world, Ols Tjikko, in Sweden. Photo by Pal Magnus Tommervold.

Rakel once compared her love and Harry Hole’s to the root system of the oldest tree in the world, Old Tjikko, in Sweden. Photo by Pal Magnus Tommervold.

ALSO by Nesbo:  Harry Hole serises:   THE BAT,      COCKROACHES,     THE REDBREAST,     NEMESIS,     THE DEVIL’S STAR,       THE REDEEMER,     SNOWMAN,     THE LEOPARD,     PHANTOM,      POLICE,     THIRST (2017)      

Olav Johansen series :  BLOOD ON SNOW (2015 ),      MIDNIGHT SUN (2015)

Photos.  The author’s photo appears on https://www.post-gazette.com

The Ramones’ Road to Ruin is an album which Harry Hole greatly admired and discussed several times in the novel.  Author Jo Nesbo is, himself, a musician with a band in Norway.  https://en.wikipedia.org/

Lyder Sagens Gate is the site of a dramatic conversation between Harry and Bjorn Holm about the murderer of his friend.  It is now the site of a music school.  https://mapio.net

Smestaddammen, an Oslo lake and park, is where a murder takes place late in the novel.  The killer was hiding across the lake when he fired his shots.  https://akersposten.no/

Old Tjikko, in Sweden, reminds Harry of Rakel’s comparison between the roots of that oldest tree in the world and her love for Harry:  https://akersposten.no/

KNIFE
REVIEW. PHOTOS. Mystery, Thriller, Noir, Nordic Noir, Norway, Psychological study
Written by: Jo Nesbo
Published by: Knopf
Date Published: 07/09/2019
ISBN: 978-0525655398
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

 

“Your father certainly didn’t teach you anything, having gotten it into his head that you were born knowing everything.  No one brought you up.  And you turned out pretty oblivious.  Though I’m not sure you would have been less oblivious if you’d had a better upbringing.  Your sisters are maybe less oblivious than you are but they’re peculiar too and oblivious, one of them in one respect and the other in another.  I didn’t teach them anything. Or maybe I taught them something but it was the wrong thing, because sometimes I feel like a person I don’t like very much.”  Adriana, mother of Michele, in a letter to him.

cover happinessOriginally published in Italy in 1973, under the title Caro Michele (Dear Michele), Natalia Ginzburg’s most popular Italian novel changed its title for an English-speaking audience in this new edition.  Happiness, as Such, the English title, conveys the author’s purpose, emphasizing the uncertainties of knowing exactly what happiness is on a grand scale, the major point of this novel, and applies to a broader cast of characters than just “dear” Michele, the “oblivious” son of a forty-three-year-old mother whose life is a melding of strange experiences with uncertain goals and values.  Told through a series of letters, primarily between Adriana, the mother, and twenty-one-year-old Michele, her son, the letters reveal the often interconnected stories of several other characters – family, friends, and lovers, past and present – as they go about living and describing their daily lives.  Author Ginzburg, whose style is so unpretentious and seemingly spontaneous that a reader cannot help but become involved in the various narratives, gradually shows how each person protects his/her happiness by doing whatever seems right at the time in order to escape misery, unpleasant consequences, and time-consuming self-analysis.  As she reveals her characters, author Ginzburg herself begins to come alive, a person of ironic humor, witty insights, and immense sensitivity to hidden meanings as revealed in seemingly ordinary dialogue.

Illustration by Cristiana Couceiro; photograph by Vittoriano Rastelli

Illustration by Cristiana Couceiro; photograph by Vittoriano Rastelli

Adriana, who controls the narrative, is the divorced mother of five, Michele and his four sisters.  His sister Angelica, who also plays an important role in the exchange of letters, is married, with a child. Sister Viola, also married, runs her own household, and the fourteen-year-old twins are still in school.   When the mother Adriana and her husband, an artist, ended their marriage several years ago, Michele, who also had visions of being an artist, went to live with his father, while the girls stayed with their mother.  Adriana has always blamed this separation for the fact that Michele is a mystery to her:  “I think about how superficially we pass judgment on each other.  I think you’re a moron,” she tells him.  “But I don’t know if you’re a moron.  Maybe you’re secretly wise.”  Since Adriana is the primary point of view, the reader, too, is often unclear about who Michele actually is, and as the hidden stories are revealed among the characters, Michele’s personal story becomes a major issue for the entire family.  When he moves suddenly from Rome to London without telling his mother, saying only that he planned to study sculpting there, his mother wants to know what, or whom, he is running away from. He does not return for the funeral of his father, a few days later, and then, just as suddenly, moves from London to Leeds, where he marries an American divorcee whom he has just met a few days earlier. 

When Mara is riding with Osvaldo and his daughter, they stop at the house where his wife and the family live. Mara tells him she dislikes the color.

When Mara is riding with Osvaldo and his daughter, they stop at the house in Trastevere where his wife and the family live. Mara’s comment is that she dislikes the red color.

As needy as Michele has been in Rome, his long-distance neediness is even greater, and the family seems to continue enabling it. He asks his sister Angelica to get all the documents that he will need to get married, just as she earlier helped him out by disposing of a gun he says he had been hiding for a friend in his apartment in Rome. He continues to borrow money from his family. Nonchalant references to a “group” he belongs to, and even a possible fascist spy in the group, float through the narrative and give a sense of secret activities in Rome.  Michele also writes to Angelica asking her to find a place for one of his friends to stay in Rome, and then asks her to call on Mara Castorelli, a major character in this novel, to whom he earlier gave money for an abortion that she never had, and who now has a twenty-two day-old baby which might be his. 

Angelica lives near Chiesa Nuova.

Angelica lives near Chiesa Nuova.

Mara proves to be one of the most vibrant – and selfish – characters in the narrative. Like Michele, Mara depends on others for money, places to stay, and food, and is flexible about whom she “loves.”  She has even left her baby with a friend so she can work in an interesting job, though the baby is only three weeks old.  In a letter she assures Michele that they had fun together and that she didn’t want anything from him, though she casually bemoans the fact that “You really hurt my feelings that one time that you arrived late for our date, and you were out of breath and pale.  You told me you’d run over [someone].  Later…you told me she was dead.”  She confesses, in her self-absorbed way, “I don’t want to marry you because you hurt me that time and a lot of other times, too.”  Totally lacking in perspective, she has already started thinking about marrying an important person she works with, one she calls “the pelican,” for whom she “does the great favor of living with him in his house and spending the money that he doesn’t need.”  Neither she nor Michele believes in happiness, per se.

Tower on Isola del Giglio, like the one which Michele inherited from his father. Photo by Ramona Partelli.

Tower on Isola del Giglio, like the one which Michele inherited from his father. Photo by Ramona Partelli.

Gradually, the reader comes to know several more characters as they search for happiness.  The conclusion forces a sense of reality to intrude into the lives of these characters, though the degree to which they are able to process reality and still seek what they regard as happiness remains a question.  Life goes on, and on, and on, for them and as their sense of happiness changes, almost day by day, their lack of absolute values and sense of commitment make every crisis a new experience.  No sense of resolution seems to accompany the biggest events in the characters’ lives, primarily because none of them give much thought to where they are going and who they are.  It is the moment that lives for them, and life seems to be a series of disconnected moments – some happy, some sad – over which they believe they have no control.  Seizing the moment works, but these moments tend to be short because, as one character points out, memory is limited, with most people “moving forward without ever looking back.”  Few others recognize that each moment has “extraordinary splendor” within, as they continue on in their perpetual search for “Happiness, as Such.”

ALSO by Natalia Ginzburg, THE DRY HEART (1947)   and  VOICES IN THE EVENING (1961)

Photos.  The author’s photo is an illustration by Cristiana Couceiro; photograph by Vittoriano Rastelli.  https://www.newyorker.com/

The Piazza in Trastevere includes this red house, for which Mara expressed her dislike to the family which lived there.  https://www.videoblocks.com/

Angelica lived near the Chiesa Nuova and parked her car there.  http://www.itmap.it/

Michele inherited the tower building on Isola del Giglio from his father.  No one was sure what to do with it.  Photo by Ramona Partelli.  https://www.flickr.com/

HAPPINESS, AS SUCH
REVIEW. PHOTOS. Classic Novel, Historical, Literary, Social and Political Issues
Written by: Natalia Ginzburg
Published by: New Directions
Date Published: 06/25/2019
ISBN: 978-0811227995
Available in: Ebook Paperback

“Ever since I was a university student, I’ve loved the copperplate prints of the Italian artist, Giovanni Battista Piranesi.  Piranesi left many sombre prints of prisons.  He was a portrayer of imaginary prisons.  Floor upon floor of high ceilings and dark metal staircases and also towers and aerial walkways.  And of course metal drawbridges.  His prints were full of those kinds of things.  I wanted to build this house in that image.  I even thought about calling it “Piranese Mansion.” – Kozaburo Hamamoto, owner/builder of the Crooked House.

cover soji shimada murder crooked houseFrom the opening lines of this locked-room mystery, author Soji Shimada piques the reader’s interest in the odd kinds of architecture which particularly lend themselves to mysterious events, describing, first, Cheval’s Palais Ideal (ca. 1916), a small rambling castle built by Ferdinand Cheval, a postman who picked up stones along his mail route to use in building his “palace.”  Ludwig II’s Linderhof Palace (ca. 1886), with its cave and underground lake, oyster shell-shaped boat, blue lighting, and romantic paintings, might also have been ideal for such a mystery, as would some of the modern geometric design and architecture of Antonio Gaudi in the early twentieth century, he suggests.  Ultimately, Shimada sets this newly translated 1982 mystery, the second novel of his career, at the top of Japan’s northernmost island, Hokkaido, facing the sea, in a fictional building designed by the main character, Kozaburo Hamamoto.  From the outset, the author stresses that Hamamoto’s house is a very special creation, with floors that are not level and a tower with the same five degree tilt as the Tower of Pisa.  Other irregularities with stairs, drawbridges, ladders, doors, and locks make the house seem more like the wild engravings of Giovanni Batista Piranesi than the “civilized” work of earlier architects, even those who stretched the concepts of home architecture in their own day.

soji shimadaThis unique fictional residence is the setting for a celebration of Christmas, 1983, as owner Kozaburo Hamamoto, a widower, has invited eight guests to spend the holiday weekend with him at the Crooked House, also called the Ice Floe Mansion.  The full-time residents of the house include Hamamoto, who, in addition to being the house owner is also the president of an industrial company; his daughter;  a married couple who act as butler, chauffeur, and housekeeper; and a live-in chef, all of whom are happy to share the holidays with their guests.  The guests who join the household for the weekend include a man who is president of a manufacturing company, his secretary/mistress, his chauffeur, an executive of his company, and three college students.  Author Shimada, a perfectionist regarding details of all kinds, includes a Dramatis Personae, identifying all these characters, and a drawing of the house, officially the Ice Floe Mansion, showing its numbered rooms, the staircases, and the drawbridge to the tower.  A special addendum also identifies the library, display room for art works, salon, sports equipment storeroom, table tennis room, kitchen and study.

A great admirer of the prison designs by Piranesi, Kozaburo Hamamoto, was attracted to the designs for staircases, drawbridges, ropes, and beams.

A great admirer of the prison designs by Giovanni Batista Piranesi, Kozaburo Hamamoto, was attracted to the designs for staircases, drawbridges, ropes, and beams when he built his house. Click to enlarge.

Elements of mystery begin immediately, as one of the students, who had been helping to decorate the Christmas tree earlier, looks out the window into the garden and sees a thin stake sticking out of the snow.  It had not been there earlier.  He is even more surprised when he sees a second stake in the snow a bit later.  He forgets about this as the host suggests they solve some mysteries which he will present to them as entertainment.  No matter how difficult these puzzles may seem, one guest, a student, manages to solve all of them.  Hamamoto, however, has one more mystery to challenge them, and they must all go to his tower to see it.  Looking out the window, he points at the garden at the base of the tower and asks his guests to figure out the significance of the design of the flower bed below the tower, a garden which must be in that exact spot, with no leeway allowed in any direction.  No one is successful in completing this task, but the guests are encouraged to keep working on it and, perhaps, return to the room another day to view the garden from above.  That night, one of the women wakens to hear faint noises very close to her, then a metallic sound.  Panicked, she screams, then sees a face with crazy eyes, charred skin on the cheeks, and a frostbitten nose staring at her through a gap in the curtains.  Since her room is well above ground level and offers no foothold, she knows the face could not really have been looking inside, but she also knows that what she saw was not a dream – she had heard the creature roar.

Golem and his puppet.

Golem and his puppet from the 1915 silent film, The Golem and the Dancing Girl.  The actor is on the right, the puppet on the left.

At breakfast time, one guest does not answer his door, and outside the room a dark figure is lying in the snow.  As the guests go outside to get closer, they see that there are objects strewn around the figure.  The “body,” however, turns out to be one of  Hamamoto’s antique puppet dolls from Czechoslovakia – a Golem – with a missing head.  When they return to the house, they find the body of a chauffeur who has come with one of the guests, stabbed to death with a hunting knife which has a white string attached.  There are no footprints around, and no clues to how it happened or how it might be related to the earlier-discovered stakes, the golem, the noises heard by the woman that evening, or the golem’s missing head.  When Hokkaido investigators arrive to do their jobs, they are as stymied by the murder – and several successive crimes, including another murder – as the guests, and they are just as unfamiliar with the bizarre architecture of this “mansion” as the guests have been.  The arrival of Kiyoshi Mitarai with the constable of the local police station brings a whole new element into the story:  Mitarai is a fortune teller, psychic, and self-styled detective, and he suddenly and dramatically becomes the new first person point of view for remainder of the novel.

Tengu masks play a role in the conclusion of the novel.

Tengu masks play a role in the conclusion of the novel.

Author Soji Shimada goes overboard here as he sets up seemingly unlimited barriers to the solving of crimes for which almost none of the guests have alibis.  As the guests interact, some resentments, past histories, and jealousies are revealed, but these are buried so deeply in all the “atmosphere” of architecture and the excruciatingly detailed descriptions of the methods and materials of the murder that the characterizations feel incidental. When the final crime takes place, many readers will know who the murderer has to be, but the ways in which that person manages to outwit everyone else are so outlandish, unpredictable, and esoteric that I doubt that any reader will have any clue about how the murders actually took place before the Great Reveal at the end fills in the blanks.  Sacrificing characterization for technique, Shimada makes this one of the most complex locked room mysteries ever, one to admire instead of love.

Photos.  The author’s photo appears on https://archive.shine.cn

A great admirer of the prison designs by Giovanni Batista Piranesi, Kozaburo Hamamoto, was attracted to the designs for staircases, drawbridges, ropes, and beams when he built his house.  This Piranese prison engraving is from 1761.  https://commons.wikimedia.org/

This Golem and his puppet star in a Berlin silent film from 1915, The Golem and the Dancing Girl, starring Paul Wegener as the Golem.  In this photo, the real Wegener is on the right, the puppet on the left.  https://www.jmberlin.de/

Hamamoto’s collection of Tengu masks like this one have a role in the conclusion.  https://www.kisspng.com/

MURDER IN THE CROOKED HOUSE
REVIEW. PHOTOS. Classic Novel, Historical, Japan, Locked room Mystery
Written by: Soji Shimada
Published by: Pushkin Vertigo
Date Published: 06/25/2019
ISBN: 978-1782274568
Available in: Ebook Paperback

“Tell me the truth,” I said.
 “What truth?” he echoed.  He was making a rapid sketch
in his notebook and now he showed me what it was: a long,
long train with a big cloud of black smoke swirling over it,
and himself leaning out of a window to wave a handkerchief.
    I shot him between the eyes. – Opening lines of this book.

dry heart cover_When she died in 1991 at the age of seventy-five, Italian author Natalia Ginzburg was described in her New York Times obituary as “an author commonly ranked with Umberto Eco as one of Italy’s most important writers of fiction.”  Few English-speaking readers will recognize her name, however, despite the fact that she was published from an early age by Italian publisher Giulio Einaudi, who was also the publisher of Italo Calvino, Cesare Pavese, Primo Levi and other world famous Italian authors.  Now two of Ginzburg’s works, The Dry Heart, originally published in 1947, when she was thirty-one, and Happiness, As Such (originally entitled Caro Michele), published in 1973, have just been reprinted in English by New Directions Publishing, giving American readers a new opportunity to experience the fine, understated writing of this neglected author. 

The Dry Heart shows little trace of the agonies which Ginzburg must have faced in her personal life in the years immediately preceding the book’s publication.  During World War II, she had escaped military arrest and imprisonment by using a pen name while she and her husband ran an anti-Fascist newspaper. Her husband, however, was arrested and tortured to death in 1944, leaving her to care for their three children. In The Dry Heart, her first novel after the war, she shows no resentments, however.  Instead she deals with the “world writ small” telling the story of the marriage of an uncommunicative and unnamed woman married to an even more uncommunicative man.  Less than a hundred words after the novel opens, the conclusion is revealed:  “I shot him between the eyes,” a statement of great drama because of the context’s lack of drama.

author photoUsing the woman’s point of view, the author carefully shifts back and forth in time, illustrating what happens, and more importantly, what often does not happen, in this marriage.  Matching her realistic style to the undramatic nature of the marriage, Ginzburg slowly builds the tensions, eventually revealing everything the reader needs to know about the past which will explain the bold admission of murder in the first few words.   On the night of the murder, the woman’s husband Alberto had asked her to give him something hot to take on a trip, and she had dutifully made tea with milk and sugar, taking it back to his study.  When he shows her the sketch he has been working on, however, she shoots him with the revolver from his desk drawer: “For a long time already I had known that sooner or later I should do something of the sort.”  Unperturbed, she puts on her raincoat and gloves, goes out, drinks a cup of coffee at a cafe, and walks “haphazardly” throughout the city.  The couple had been married for four years, and he had threatened to leave her many times, but they had never officially ended the relationship until she ended it with murder.

A rural Italian village similar to the one in which the speaker grew up and to which she returns on vacations.

This rural Italian village is similar to the one in which the speaker grew up and to which she returns on vacations.

Sitting on a bench in the deserted park, the woman reviews her marriage, knowing that if she goes to the police, she will have to go back to the beginning of their relationship to explain the circumstances leading up to the murder. Instead she reviews it for herself – and the reader. Daughter of a country doctor, the woman is a twenty-six-year-old teacher from Maona, who has been introduced to forty-year-old Alberto at the home of a doctor she knows in Rome, where she is living.  She is attracted to Alberto’s “gay and sparkling” eyes, and she begins to think he is attracted to her, but she has no romantic interest in him, thinking instead that she might meet someone she really likes through him if they become friends.  While she shares her feelings throughout their contacts with each other, Alberto shares nothing, saying only that he lives with his mother, who is “old and failing.”  Summer vacation arrives, and the woman returns to the country to stay with her family.  He does not write to her, except for a single postcard, but when she returns to the city at the end of summer, she is still expecting Alberto to visit.  Obsessed with the uncertainty after several days, she consoles herself by imagining a relationship, and when Alberto does finally see her, “I looked at him and tried to recognize in this little man with the curly black hair the cause of all my anguish and torment.  I felt cold and humiliated by his failure to call or to stop by.”  Still, she soon convinces herself that she is in love with him, and confesses that to him.  He never says that he loves her in return, though they do marry.

Throughout the novel, many references occur to the Duino Elegies by Rilke, made by various characters.

Throughout the novel, the various characters make many references to the Duino Elegies by Rainer Maria Rilke.

Alberto lies continuously during their marriage, and a month after they marry, he disappears for ten days, insisting, upon his return, that he has been alone.  A few months later, he disappears again, and again, and again, each time for a couple of weeks, while his wife keeps herself functioning during his absences during those the months, and eventually years, by reminding herself of his declaration, not of love, but that “You’re all I’ve got.  Just remember that.” Eventually, however, these words “lost their sweetness, like a prune stone that has been sucked too long.” Ultimately, it is one of Alberto’s friends who tells her about a woman with whom Alberto has been having an affair, off and on for over ten years.  Still the wife refuses to give up on the marriage, and even on the day of Alberto’s death, she is still serving him his tea.

The novella, which benefits from being read in one sitting, feels “ordinary” and familiar in terms of its characters as they deal with their stories of frustrated love, however extreme their behavior, and those who enjoy carefully crafted, often subtle, and deliberate writing will especially enjoy the pacing of this novel and its structure.  Though none of the critics I have read have suggested any satire here, I cannot help but wonder how much of this novella may be slyly satiric, especially considering the commitment of the author to freedom from Fascism during World War II.  Here a decidedly unliberated female finally takes action against a husband who has betrayed her for four years, deciding murder is the only answer. The control the author exerts over the pacing and atmosphere is deliberate, and the ultimate outcome for the wife is never stated outright, though the unstated ultimate result is clear. 

ALSO by Ginzburg:  HAPPINESS, AS SUCH   and   VOICES IN THE EVENING

Photos.  The author’s photo appears on https://www.pinterest.com/

The female speaker grew up in a rural hill town, Maona, perhaps similar to this one:  https://www.alamy.com/

Throughout the novel, characters refer to the Duino Elegies by Rainer Maria Rilke.  This edition is part of by the European Poetry Classics series by Northwestern University.  http://www.nupress.northwestern.edu/

THE DRY HEART
REVIEW. PHOTOS. Historical, Italy, Literary, Psychological study, Social and Political Issues
Written by: Natalia Ginzburg
Published by: New Directions.
Date Published: 06/25/2019
ISBN: 978-0811228787
Available in: Ebook Paperback

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »