Feed on
Posts
Comments

Eugen Ruge–CABO DE GATA

Note: Eugen Ruge was WINNER of the German Book Prize for his previous novel, In Times of Fading Light.

“I remember my surprise at suddenly finding myself in my kitchen, in exactly the same attitude…that I had carried out in just the same way the morning before (and the morning before the morning before), and for a moment I had the feeling that it was the same morning and I was the same man, a man who like the undead, was doomed to repeat the same sequence again and again.”–Peter Handke, narrator of this novel.

cover cabo de gataAuthor Eugen Ruge grew up in East Berlin during the time of the Berlin Wall and lived there, working as an academic, till the age of thirty-four, leaving the East for the West a year before the Wall fell, and perhaps it is this background which has inspired him to create a main character like Peter Handke.  Handke, also a man from Berlin, has lost his sense of direction, and he has decided to start over in a new country.  Not as young as he seems, he is a former professor of chemical engineering with a well-paid, permanent position, one he has recently resigned in order to become a writer. He has had only minimal success since then.  Handke is disconnected from those around him, a profound loss of motivation preventing him from making needed changes in his world.  In another environment, he believes, he will be able to write the novel he has always dreamed of. Though his father, also a writer, considers his own work in history and philosophy to be far more important than Peter’s work (mostly light satire, to date), he nevertheless gives him some funds to help him get started in a new country. The attitude he conveys, however, leads Peter to confess that “I seemed to myself rather dull-witted,” not a happy thought for someone planning to create a new life.

eugen-ruge

A novel of absurdity which sometimes borders on the bizarre, Cabo de Gata (“Cape of the Cat”) begins with Peter’s travels from Basel to Barcelona and then on to Andalusia, the southernmost region of Spain. There he meanders long the southeast coast toward Cabo de Gata, about a hundred fifty miles due east of Malaga. His arrival there does not reflect the romantic promise that Peter expects of a place described as “a breath of Africa,” just across the Mediterranean. He “remembers the wretched (pink) buildings,” finding it hard to say “whether they are still being built or already falling into ruins,” along with mended tarmac, broken paving stones, and rocks piled up, and he feels that “the whole landscape looks like a sparsely overgrown dump.” Wind blows sand into his eyes, yapping dogs surround him as he walks, and the church and a row of tiny, two-story houses show no signs of life. He is stunned, reflecting like a film director that “if I seem to myself in those long minutes like a character from a film, it may be because I keep my hat on throughout this entire scene.”

Cabo de Gata

Cabo de Gata

The author’s close attention to detail enables the reader to see the world through Peter Handke’s eyes as he first decides to leave Cabo de Gata, and then later decides to stay. At one point during a walk along the “beach,” he finds a spiral conch shell and decides to take it home, only to discover that inside the shell a pair of “black button eyes” belonging to a hermit crab look out, though the crab itself is dead. Since Peter’s sign of the zodiac is Cancer the Crab, he thinks this may be an omen that he should stay, and fascinated by a group of small birds which he thinks of as “hysterical aunties,” he eventually lets loose with a loud shout. “I think it was simply a cry of rage, not of triumph, not a liberating roar, but a short sound of blatant annoyance that an outsider might have taken as my reaction of an insect bite.”

Cabo de Gato

Flamingos, Cabo de Gata

Eventually renting a small room for three months, managed by the  grumpy old woman who runs the only café, Peter Handke begins his new life. Not having a desk in his tiny room, he writes sitting on a bench outside, and when he wants to take a break to read, he lies in bed with the only book he has brought with him, Henry Miller’s The Colossus of Maroussi. Gradually, he comes to feel comfortable in his walks along the promenade and begins to have a “strong sense of belonging to all this,” his change of attitude leading him to tear out a first sentence he’s written in his notebook in favor of a newer, more positive opening. He discovers a shallow lake filled with flamingos, “and it seems to me entirely absurd, positively deranged, to doubt the existence of God.” The arrival of an Englishman who leaves after two days, and later an American who vanishes in a storm leave Peter alone again, and he decides to pay more attention to the people who live there while contemplating life’s biggest questions and analyzing his dreams. Can the world really be perceived? Is the world on television the real world and the world he lives in an illusion, or the other way around? Eventually, a feral cat appears in his life, and changes his approach to the world as he tries to tame her. As she stalks like a lion, he is reminded that his deceased mother was a Leo, and he begins to draw some bizarre conclusions about external forces.

map s. spain_1

Cabo de Gata is about 150 miles due east of Malaga, on a point. Click to enlarge.

The novel ends without a clear resolution, adding to the feeling that this novel defies all the “rules” and presents itself on its own terms. Peter Handke is not a “hero” or even an anti-hero. He is too neutral and uncommunicative to attract the long-term interest of the reader, and his journey is a solitary one, with no antagonist, other than life itself, to fight him. He raises questions but does not come to many conclusions, and those he does draw are often offbeat and darkly comic. There is some satire in Peter’s search for philosophical answers (perhaps a rebellion against his father the philosopher), and the novel is clever and written with exquisitely descriptive prose (beautifully translated by Anthea Bell). The “Seven Puzzles of Cabo de Gato,” written as if they were the seven biggest mysteries of the world – Peter’s world – are one of the novel’s highlights, with the author obviously having fun, and the use of a feral cat as a possible deus ex machina is clever and fun to read. Readers who can be satisfied with letting the novel unfold on its own terms will enjoy this unusual and often humorous creation which offers more than mere laughs.

Photos, in order:  The author’s photo appears on http://www.plotpoint.ch/

Fishing boat on the rough coast and beach of Cabe de Gata.  http://www.juntadeandalucia.es

The flamingos of Cabo de Gata attract many visitors each year to southeast Spain.  http://www.juntadeandalucia.es

Cabo de Gata is about 150 miles due east of Malaga, on the coast. This red line represents the itinerary of a bird-watching program.  Click to enlarge.  http://www.avg-w.com/

ARC:  Graywolf Press

CABO DE GATA
REVIEW. Experimental, Humor, Satire, Absurdity, Literary, Psychological study, Spain, Germany,
Written by: Eugen Ruge
Published by: Graywolf Press
Date Published: 11/01/2016
Edition: Translation by Anthea Bell
ISBN: 978-1555977573
Available in: Ebook Paperback

“It is the eyes that make the picture great. The soldier’s eyes look out directly from the page. They look out and through – or perhaps they are not looking at all but seeing only what they have seen already, images that are imprinted on the retina and on the memory so strongly that they cannot be supplanted by whatever is before them now. This soldier has seen horrors first hand. Perhaps he has been a perpetrator….” – speaker Jonathan Ashe, photographer, in Vietnam.

cover gun roomLike so many other young men in the 1960s, Jonathan Ashe, a young man from a farm in rural Norfolk, England, has escaped his small village to travel the world and, on some level, to find out who he really is. He and his older brother, who has been left in charge of the family farm following the death of his father, have little in common, and some event from the past has alienated them. Though he has feelings for his mother, he cannot bring himself to write to her on a regular basis. Now in Viet Nam, half a world away from England, Jonathan decides to challenge himself as a photographer during the Vietnam War, anxious to expand his views of the world in an effort to understand more about life and death and survival.   Jonathan’s own father died of an accidental gunshot wound when Jonathan was a young child, and the suddenness of the death and the memories he has of the aftermath have haunted Jonathan ever since. Now he as he thinks back on his childhood, he wonders how much of what we remember about a person or event is actually real and how much is what we wish for – or what we choose to remember? Can we ever learn to see traumatic experiences in new ways without lying to ourselves and others about the realities?

Georgina

Georgina Harding

Jonathan hopes that viewing the world through the uncompromising lens of a camera will provide him with some new understandings. In Vietnam he accepts a ride in a helicopter from a young pilot who is about to fly over a battle site, thereby setting in motion his personal quest to observe, digest, and live with some of life’s most difficult truths. In clear language and a style which is so simple in its structure that it sometimes resembles poetry, British author Georgina Harding follows Jonathan as he sees a reality more horrific than he has ever imagined. Arriving at the scene of a battle in the copter piloted by his new friend, Jonathan is at first disappointed that the battle is essentially over, but as they are looking for a place to land, he sees a young woman, screaming and clutching her belly, severely wounded. Out of the corner of his eye, he thinks he sees an American soldier running toward her and firing at her head, but he cannot be sure. A few minutes later, when the chopper lands, Jonathan gets out and hurries toward the smoke, “and then he [sees] the soldier…very still…seated on the ground with his back to a wall, his knees bent up in front of him and his two hands clamped to the barrel of the gun held upright between them…Beyond the soldier, the village. The houses were burning.”

war is hell (1)

Taking a quick picture of the soldier, who is unmoving and silent, he moves on to see dead bodies crumpled on the ground, seemingly stopped in mid-action, dead children and pets with legs all entangled, and numerous bodies floating in the river, obviously shot from above. Soon he finds the body of the wounded woman he had previously seen from the air – a young woman, the mother of a baby. She has a new wound in the center of her forehead. He takes a picture of her, and moves on. On the way back to the chopper, he once again sees the soldier by the wall – he has not moved an inch in the forty-five minutes that have passed, and continues to stare straight ahead, completely oblivious to all that is happening. Jonathan takes a second picture of this stunned soldier, then returns to base, packs everything he owns, and hastens back to Saigon, well out of the field of battle. While there, he learns from the radio that an atrocity has occurred in the village that he has just photographed. He responds to the news, and his photos of this village – and especially his iconic photo of the stunned soldier – soon appear all over the world.

HIroshige snow

“Snowfall” by Ando Hiroshige

This beginning contains the seed of every other event which follows in the novel. No further warfare and no more bloodshed occur, but Harding’s purposes – to show the more personal and long-lasting effects of trauma and the more universal aspects of responsibility and humanity – develop with insight and deep feeling, as Jonathan Ashe, his last name appropriate to his role in the novel, moves on to Japan and a new life. Teaching English to Japanese students, “Jonathan tries to become part of society there, taking pictures wherever he goes, but even he sees that “All that is in his pictures when he first comes to Japan seems material, except the sky.” He is surprised by how cold Japan can be in February, though he has long been familiar with the Hiroshige prints of snow falling. He takes long walks, believing that “the less he held to himself, the more he gave to the crowd, the more he would be part of the place, understanding it in its present.” He finds a favorite bar, which he enjoys at night, but he does not really connect with others until he meets Kumiko. The story of their relationship, which depends on her patience and insight, rather than any genuine commitment on his part, provides much of the drama and pleasure of the novel.

Jonathan is intrigued by the fact that if he brings a bottle of whiskey to a bar in Japan, they will hold it for him and use it for him alone when he orders whiskey.

Jonathan is intrigued by the fact he can buy a bottle of whiskey in a bar in Japan, and they will put his name on it and use it for him alone when he orders whiskey. Note individual names on bottles in Japanese.

Several overlapping events connect the various parts of the novel. Jonathan Ashe’s father had been a soldier in World War II and had fought in India, Assam, and Burma, where he had fought the Japanese in the jungle and never really recovered. Kumiko’s grandfather now senile, fought the British in Burma, and was so traumatized that even now he insists that his garden always be tidy and neatly trimmed so that it does not resemble the jungle in which he fought. As Jonathan notes,

“War is the most concrete thing. The memory of war will stay with a man longer than anything else he will ever know.”

Shinjiuku Gyoen, a public garden that Jonathan and Kumiko enjoyed visiting.

Shinjuku Gyoen, a public garden that Jonathan and Kumiko enjoyed visiting.

British Jonathan and Japanese Kumiko must work their way through much family history, culture, and Jonathan’s own trauma in order to reach a meaningful understanding, and when Jonathan, walking down the street, suddenly sees the soldier he once photographed in Vietnam during the shooting of the young woman, he follows him, eventually meeting and coming to know him and his girlfriend and gaining some new insights about himself. Harding keeps her style simple and quiet, and except for one unlikely coincidence, the novel resonates with honesty and truth, as Jonathan begins to find out what he needs to do to feel happy, ending the novel on an upbeat note.

ALSO by Georgina Harding:  THE PAINTER OF SILENCE

Photos, in order:  The author’s photo appears on http://www.vertigolibri.it/

The war photo from the Vietnam War, “War is Hell,” is from http://www.businessinsider.com/

“Snowfall” by Adro Hiroshige may be found here:  http://www.dominicanajournal.org

Bottle storage at some bars in Japan, where people buy bottles for their exclusive use, over time, each carrying his/her own name is described on http://www.japan-talk.com/jt/

Shinjuku Gyoen, a public garden in Shinjuku, is a place where Jonathan enjoyed walking with Kumiko:  http://www.urbancapture.com/

ARC:  Bloomsbury

THE GUN ROOM
REVIEW. Book Club Suggestions, Historical, Japan, Literary, Psychological study, Social and Political Issues, Vietnam, England
Written by: Georgina Harding
Published by: Bloomsbury
Date Published: 11/15/2016
ISBN: 978-1632864369
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

Note: Thomas Keneally was WINNER of the Booker Prize for Schindler’s List (Ark)  in 1982.  He is a two-time WINNER of Australia’s highest award, the Miles Franklin Award in 1967 and 1968, and has been WINNER of the Peggy V. Helmerich Distinguished Author Award in 2007.

“[Boney] turned to me, his eyes playful, and waved his finger in front of my face as if to get my attention, and reached forward and chose an ear that happened to have been pierced the day before. He knew it had been pierced, too… And now he squeezed it…inflicting pain as children do, and with the same fierce intent of children.” –Betsy Balcombe, age thirteen, during an encounter with Napoleon in his exile on St. Helena, 1815.

cover nap. last islandIn 2012 Australian author Thomas Keneally’s prodigious imagination was captured by a special exhibition of “Napoleon’s garments, uniforms, furniture, china, paintings, snuffboxes, military decorations, and memorabilia” on display at the National Gallery of Victoria in Melbourne. There he also found two gorgeous women’s dresses, made in France and displayed there on mannequins, furniture commissioned by Jacob Frere “who might have come as close to Heaven in their creation as any furniture maker in history,” porcelain and plate, paintings by Jacques-Louis David, a swatch of Napoleon’s hair, and a death mask. With a smirk in his “voice,” Keneally comments that he was “bowled over” by what he saw, explaining that “we people of the globe’s southernmost regions are used to going to Europe on interminable, brain-numbing flights to gawp at such items, but to do it in Australia was a delight.”

t. keneally photoThe exhibition catalogue featured the name of Betsy Balcombe and information about her and her family, people Napoleon knew during his exile on the tiny island of St. Helena, halfway between South America and Africa. Betsy was thirteen when Napoleon arrived there, and, author Keneally discovered, she and her family themselves were eventually exiled to Australia, bringing their mementoes of Napoleon with them. The exhibition, Betsy’s own journal, two volumes by Barry O’Meara (Napoleon’s physician on St. Helena), and journals by other friends of Napoleon on the island  inspired Keneally to write this novel, which he describes as fiction “purporting to be a secret journal, the one hidden behind the real one” by Betsy Balcombe, published in 1844.

Photo Betsy Balcombe's portrait from Margaret Rodenberg. See photo credits below.

Photo of Betsy Balcombe’s portrait from Margaret Rodenberg. See photo credits below.

The novel’s beginning suggests Betsy’s own journal, being told in the first person by a young woman in England who has met her husband-to-be and who has just received word of Napoleon’s death, the details of which she and her parents learn from Barry O’Meara. Napoleon’s death in 1821, just six years after his arrival on the island, and only a few years after the Balcombes have been forced to leave the island for England, occur in the first twenty pages of the novel, which then flashes back. Part II, “Before OGF” (Our Good Friend) describes the Balcombes’ early lives on St. Helena, with intriguing descriptions of the island, the people there, their livelihoods, and their families. Betsy’s father William has become successful by maintaining a supply depot there for the East India Company.  The arrival of Napoleon and his small entourage, and the lack of a ready place for him to stay, leads to his staying in the guest “pavilion” of the Briars, the home of the Balcombes, until his own house, Longwood, can be made ready.

The Pavilion at the Briars on St. Helena. Napoleon stayed here while construction was ongoing at Longwood, which would become his later home.

The Pavilion at the Briars on St. Helena. Napoleon stayed here while construction was ongoing at Longwood, which would become his later home.

Thirteen-year-old Betsy, as she emerges in Keneally’s captivating novel, is a perfect foil for Napoleon Bonaparte, then in his mid-forties. Exiled to this remote island with no possibility of reprieve, he has brought with him all his war-time memories, a few furnishings, some assistants, two French ladies (the owners of the clothes on display in the Melbourne museum), and a strong need to adapt to a new life. A soldier from his late teens, he has had almost no childhood, and he is enchanted by the imaginative outdoor games played by Betsy and her friends, who help fill the emptiness left by the absence of his wife and son. When Betsy Balcombe gets pinched on the ear by Napoleon (in the opening quotation), she and other children have been playing after a day of studying and translating French into their native English. Betsy, energetic and uninhibited, has no awe of Napoleon, a characteristic which charms him – she talks back, argues with him, and acts without fear. The opening quotation takes place, in fact, after she has grabbed his sword and pretended to attack him, almost drawing blood.

Longwood, Napoleon's home on St. Helena. Photo by Michel Dancoisne-Martineau:

Longwood, Napoleon’s home on St. Helena. Photo by Michel Dancoisne-Martineau:

Through all this lively description, Keneally keeps the spirit high, conveying more than physical appearances. When meeting Napoleon, Betsy’s little brothers “had had some solemnity threatened into them by our parents.” Napoleon, at dinner, quizzes them in French on country capitals, and asks Betsy who burned Moscow. As she tries to avoid accusing him of doing it, she finally responds, “What I’ve been told was that it was the Russians who burned it down to get rid of you, sir.” Napoleon’s delight in her answer sets the tone for the rest of their relationship: “I resolved,” Betsy later declares, “not to be treated with the kind of sport he clearly saw me as good for.” She later convinces her little brother to put a nasty substitute into a box of bonbons for Napoleon.

map st.helena

This tiny dot is St. Helena, between Africa and South America – and a very long way from Europe. Click to enlarge.

In later sections, Keneally uses the passage of time to develop new relationships and complications. The English governors of the island change, and with the arrival of Sir Hudson Lowe, an uncompromising man more anxious to mete out punishment than maintain peace, the Balcombe family is drawn into trying to help Napoleon in the “competition between the imperial bee [of Napoleon] and the Crown of Great Britain.” Budgets are cut back, food is more limited, and tensions rise on the island, both among the adults and among Betsy, her sister Jane, and some of the young men who may be courting them. One man is described by Betsy as “a vileness unsullied by mania and thus to be deplored.” Another is a “pink-eyed mouse.” The intense and surprising conclusion occurs after Betsy creates a social disaster which permanently affects the lives of everyone she knows. “Dry lids were my religion and indeed I would not cry now,” she declares. The island serves as a microcosm of the world in which themes of alienation and exile inform the lives of families and friends, in which life is often short and not always sweet, and in which revenge can be a potent weapon.

Napoléon à Sainte-Hélène by Francois-Joseph Sandmann

“Napoléon à Sainte-Hélène” by Francois-Joseph Sandmann

In an afterword, Keneally moves the Balcombes’ lives forward several generations to the time of the exhibition at the museum in Melbourne and the Balcombes’ eventual history there.  He never says whether the dramas of the conclusion are real or fiction, but by the time the novel ends, the reader may be so charmed that he does not have to. Elegantly written in nineteenth century style, and old-fashioned in the best possible ways, this novel completely captivated me.

ALSO by Thomas Keneally:  CONFEDERATES,     DAUGHTERS OF MARS,     SCHINDLER’S LIST,     THE TYRANT’S NOVEL,      VICTIM OF THE AURORA

Photos, in order:  The author photo appears on https://www.theguardian.com/books  Photo by  International/REX Shutterstock

The photograph of Betsy Balcombe’s portrait appears on http://www.mrodenberg.com/   Ms. Rodenberg says of this portrait on her website: “Although the Balcombes’ main house at the Briars was destroyed long ago, Napoleon’s summer pavilion has survived, with additions built on over the years.  The center room where Napoleon stayed is open to the public and contains memorabilia from his time there, including this oil painting of Betsy.” 

The Pavilion, a guest house at The Briars, where the Balcombes lived, is shown on https://whatthesaintsdidnext.com/

Longwood House, which became Napoleon’s home on St. Helena is appears on https://commons.wikimedia.org   Photo by Michel Dancoisne-Martin

The map of St. Helena is from https://www.pinterest.com/

The painting of “Napoléon à Sainte-Hélène” by Francois-Joseph Sandmann is from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Helena#/media/File:Napoleon_sainthelene.jpg

ARC:  Atria Books

NAPOLEON'S LAST ISLAND
REVIEW. Australia, Book Club Suggestions, Coming-of-age, Historical, Literary, Social and Political Issues, Napoleon, St.Helena, Exile
Written by: Thomas Keneally
Published by: Atria Books
Date Published: 10/04/2016
ISBN: 978-1501128424
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

Note:  Arnaldur was WINNER of the Glass Key award, a literature prize for the best Nordic crime novel, in 2002 and 2003. He was WINNER of the Crime Writers’ Association Gold Dagger Award in 2005 for his novel Silence of the Grave.

“Feeling drowsy, [Erlendur] laid aside the book. His thoughts shifted to the Reykjavic nights so strangely sunny and bright, yet in another sense so dark and desperate. Night after night he and his fellow officers patrolled the city in the lumbering police van, witnessing human dramas that were hidden from others. Some the night provoked and seduced; other, it wounded and terrified…”

coverIn his first Detective Erlendur novel to be published in English since 2012, Icelandic author Arnaldur Indridason provides a “prequel” to the entire series, now numbering six novels, and flashes back to a time when Erlendur is still in his twenties, establishing some of Erlandur’s background, personality, and youthful history . Here in Reykjavik Nights, Erlendur has just started working for the Reykjavik police, on the night shift, with two young law students who are working part-time for the summer, and he himself is considering whether to take classes at nearby Hamrahlid College which offers adult education classes. Most of his night-time duties consist of breaking up fights, arresting drunks, attending to the victims of automobile accidents, and reporting more serious events – sudden deaths and disappearances – some of which intrigue Erlendur enough that he follows up, unofficially, on his own. Though he does not consider himself “nocturnal,” he does not object to the night duty, having become “reconciled to the city, when its streets were finally quiet with no sound but the wind and the low chugging of the engine” of the van. A loner who has never established strong connections with his peers, and who seems to have no family, Erlendur makes few commitments, a characteristic which becomes even more dramatic in the novels of his later life in which he is almost pathologically solitary, reflecting his grim vision of reality and even grimmer vision of mankind.Indridason photo

In this novel, fans of the series will finally come to know the background which has made the older Erlendur, seen in novels like Jar City  (2005), the person he is. That novel, the first in this series to have been published in English (in 2005), is about as dark as a noir novel can be and shows Erlendur to be humorless, rigid, and often alone. That novel and the later film show Erlendur in his early fifties, more than twenty years after the setting of Reykjjavik Nights. Though we know some of the reasons Erlendur expects so little happiness from his life at that time, some of his early background has remained a mystery, and this prequel fills in many of the blanks. In the earlier Jar City  (2005), for example, Erlendur has been divorced for twenty years and has had little or no contact with his former wife. In Reykjavik Nights, recently written but set in much earlier times, we discover when and how he met the woman who became is wife and mother of his two children. Voices (2007) and The Draining Lake (2008) further develop a story of Erlendur’s childhood trauma, explaining the horrific events involving his younger brother, a continuing nightmare he mentions in Rekjavik Nights but does not fully explain.

Hamrahlid College, where Erlendur considers taking adult courses at night to supplement his spotty education.

Hamrahlid College, where Erlendur considers taking adult courses at night to supplement his spotty education.

Reykjavik Nights begins slowly and simply, befitting the prequel’s introduction to the characters and the series, and it develops slowly, as Erlendur begins to explore his new job and its responsibilities, while also testing his own responses to what he sees and how he reacts. Neither as dark nor as violent as the later novels, the emphasis here is more on character, both that of Erlendur and of the victims, some of whom who may or may not have been murdered. An especially atmospheric opening chapter describes the lives of three young boys who are playing on a homemade raft which they are poling in a pond in the wasteground of Kringlumyri. The raft gets caught up on something underwater, and after much pushing and shoving, the obstacle suddenly rises, tipping the boys into the water. When they see what they have hit, they go home, shrieking. Erlendur discovers that the obstacle is the body of a homeless man, Hannibal, whom he has tried to protect from his alcoholic demons on several occasions, rescuing him from the bitter cold and taking him to the cells for overnight on one bitterly cold evening, and on another taking him to the small building where Hannibal lives in a storeroom. As time passes, he loses track of Hannibal, but he later discovers that Hannibal has been sleeping inside a narrow conduit containing steel pipes which carry heated water to the neighborhood. When Hannibal dies, Erlendur partly blames himself for not becoming more involved, betraying a sense of responsibility and kindness which he loses somewhat as he grows older – and more jaded – in the later novels.

Erlendur enjoys walking along the waterfront, which features this Viking-inspired sculpture by Jon Gunnar Arnason.

Erlendur enjoys walking along the waterfront, which features this Viking-inspired sculpture by Jon Gunnar Arnason. Double click to enlarge

Missing people whose absence may not cause many ripples, brutalized wives who have no recourse for help, drug addicts and alcoholics who have a place to stay only if they are sober at night, tramps of both sexes who often seek solace with each other, and the those victims who have lived outside society for much of their adult lives are among the pathetic main characters Erlendur comes to know as he works his “Reykjavik nights.” In many cases, the police, unable to find the families of these homeless “outsiders,” give up on trying to investigate their deaths, often declaring them to be suicides because there is so little information available about them. Hannibal’s death continues to haunt Erlendur, however, because he has made some kind of minimal connection to him, and a year or so later, after he accidentally sees and then chats with one of the young boys who originally found Hannibal’s body, he gains a piece of information which makes him want to investigate that death on his own to assuage his sense of guilt. The discovery of an earring hidden in the pipe where Hannibal lived, gives Erlendur something tangible to keep him connected with Hannibal’s death.

Flat-topped Mt. Esja dominates the skyline over Reykjavik, as Erlendur points out.

Flat-topped Mt. Esja dominates the skyline over Reykjavik, as Erlendur points out. Click to enlarge. (The lighting here is magnificent!)

As is always the case with Indridason’s novels, he keeps the style clear and sometimes terse, but in this novel, he makes Erlendur more human. By isolating Erlendur from the family he eventually has in the later novels, it is possible to see Erlendur as a person who cares about others when he does not have the family distractions which complicate his life twenty years later. This greater emphasis on character development is a style Indridason began with Hypothermia (2010) and explored also in Outrage (2012), a novel in which Erlendur does not appear at all but which features a female officer who works with him. Indridason continues to develop his craft, taking chances with new techniques, and becoming less dependent on violence and dark action to sustain interest.

ALSO by Indridason:  THE DRAINING LAKE (2008),     HYPOTHERMIA (2010)     JAR CITY (2005),      OUTRAGE (2012),     VOICES (2007),     OPERATION NAPOLEON (2011),     INTO OBLIVION (2017)

Photos, in order: The author’s photo appears on http://www.babelio.com/

Hamrahlid College, a nearby college where adults can take part-time courses, is a possibility that the under-educated Erlendur is exploring.  http://mapio.net/

This iconic Viking-inspired sculpture by Jon Gunnar Arnason is a highlight of the Reykjavik waterfront.  https://www.pinterest.com/pin/40321359143024732/

Flat-topped Mt. Esja dominates the skyline of Reykjavik:  http://icelandmag.visir.is/

ARC: Picador

REYKJAVIK NIGHTS
REVIEW. Iceland, Mystery, Thriller, Noir, Nordic Noir, Social and Political Issues
Written by: Arnaldur Indridason
Published by: Picador
Date Published: 10/11/2016
ISBN: 978-1250111425
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

“It would be an appalling injustice and a condemnation of our democratic society if Jeremy [Thorpe] were to resign merely because the party is embarrassed by allegations that were untrue….On the other hand, if there is a sound basis of truth in the allegations, Jeremy Thorpe owes it to the party, which he has led so well and so ably, not to lumber us with the stark choice between apparent disloyalty and engagement in a kind of cover-up.”—Emlyn Hooson, one of thirteen Liberal MPs, in a document circulated to the other twelve members of the party, February, 1976.

cover english scandal

If you think that the machinations, the rumor-mongering, and the outright lies we have seen in the latest election cycle in the United States are as bad as it gets, take a look at journalist John Preston’s latest book of non-fiction about a scandal in England in the 1960s and 1970s. Subtitled “Sex, Lies, and a Murder Plot at the Heart of the Establishment,” Preston’s thoroughly researched and dramatically presented study of MP Jeremy Thorpe and his small coterie of friends and family, both in and out of government, gives new meaning to the idea of political egotism, at the same time that it illustrates a British sense of reserve and a respect for privacy that has now vanished from the press and our own twenty-first century lives. At a time in which there was no internet, no reality TV, and no desire to destroy lives in order to sell newspapers with stories based solely on rumor, Jeremy Thorpe’s crimes would not come to a head and result in a trial until nineteen years had elapsed from his first contact with Norman (Josiffe) Scott. Scott claims to have been a victim of rape by Thorpe when he was twenty, followed by several years of homosexual contact, both of which were against the law in the UK in 1960 when the relationship began. Scott had a nervous breakdown as a result of the attack.

John Preston

Author John Preston

During that time, Jeremy Thorpe would become the leader of the Liberal Party of Parliament and a respected politician, while Scott, whose National Insurance card was being held by Thorpe, was forced to look for work in Ireland, unable to get medical care for himself and his family. He and his family sometimes had to scrounge for vegetables left behind in the fields after harvest. Severely depressed, Scott was often unable to hold a job working as a horse trainer, and later working as a model. Thorpe, meanwhile, was enjoying his life as an MP, eventually marrying a wealthy woman and fathering a child, and he regarded Scott as a threat to his future. The death of his first wife in an accident, and his later marriage to an even more aristocratic wife added to his feeling that it could all end if Scott’s threats found sympathetic ears. Surrounding himself with a few friends who were willing to do almost anything for him, Thorpe began to think how much easier life would be if he did not have to worry about Scott.

Jeremy Thorpe

Jeremy Thorpe

One friend, a fellow MP, Peter Bessell, suggested that Thorpe’s retention of Scott’s health card might lead some to think Thorpe was blackmailing Scott, and Bessell began to pay Scott a few pounds a week to make up for the money he was unable to get for medical care. Scott, however, could not help but tell his story to others, though his accusations were not ever printed, at this early stage of the conflict. One person did describe Scott’s accusations to another MP, however, and the party did investigate in the early 1970s, ten years after Thorpe’s initial contact with Scott, but the party cleared Thorpe, leaving Scott even more frustrated. In the meantime, Thorpe was becoming powerful in Parliament and was eventually even being considered by some for the role of Prime Minister.

Norman Josiffe Scott

Norman Josiffe Scott

John Preston does a superb job of keeping all the various plot elements from becoming tangled and keeps the reader from becoming frustrated with the fairly large cast of characters. He provides essential information when it is needed, sometimes juggling the chronology in order to keep the action flowing and the pace from bogging down with long explanations of background. The characters, well depicted, are easy to imagine because of the photographs included in the middle of the book. The plethora of written material and letters between the various characters often provides the equivalence of dialogue. As years pass and Scott finds himself becoming more anxious to talk to anyone who will take him seriously, Thorpe finds himself panicking – his whole career could come to an end if Scott were to talk. Eventually, Thorpe does suggest to his stalwarts that Scott needed to go, and they take action on Thorpe’s behalf, sixteen years after the rape attack.

auberon waugh

Auberon Waugh

Though the grim comedy of errors which results from the attempted murder occurs at about the mid-point of the novel, it is by no means the climax. In 1975, thirteen years after Scott’s first contact with Jeremy Thorpe, Andrew Newton, Scott’s would-be assassin, goes on trial, and Scott finally gets his turn to talk in court. For the first time, the press begins to take interest. A year later, Newton’s release from prison generates more press interest, resulting, eventually, in trials being held for Jeremy Thorpe and his three henchmen. At this point Auberon Waugh, son of Evelyn Waugh, writes a story for his satirical column in Private Eye magazine, announcing that he plans to run against Jeremy Thorpe for Parliament and plans to make his appeal to the dog lovers throughout the district. (See information in the photo credits.) His column is one of the first to expose Jeremy Thorpe for the poseur that he has been and to involve the public in the long-overdue story of Thorpe and his treatment of Norman Scott and others. The trial is not concluded until mid-June, 1979, nineteen long years after Thorpe’s first contact with Norman Scott.

Author John Preston keeps the reader’s interest at peak as the contrasts between Thorpe’s time and culture, and present day times and culture, reveal the enormous differences between the treatment of the Thorpe scandal, its effects on his political party, and the results for the politicians involved, and life and political scandal as we see it today in the US. An element of civility and an institutionalized etiquette pervade much of the behavior of these English characters, both in politics and in the courts, leading to positive assumptions about the character of the accused, a danger at least as great for civilization in those times as the public assumption of guilt may be today.

ALSO by John Preston:  THE DIG

Photos, in order:  The author’s photo appears on http://www.telegraph.co.uk/

Jeremy Thorpe, MP, head of the Liberal Party, at his desk.  http://www.independent.co.uk

Norman (Josiffe) Scott, who endured nineteen years before getting a chance to testify against Jeremy Thorpe.  http://www.bbc.com/news/     

Auberon Waugh’s satiric commentary on the case may be found at this site:  http://flashbak.com

ARC:  Other Press

A VERY ENGLISH SCANDAL: Sex, Lies, and a Murder Plot at the Heart of the Establishment
BOOK. REVIEW. Book Club Suggestions, England, Historical, Literary, Politcs, Non-fiction, Psychological study, Social and Political Issues
Written by: John Preston
Published by: Other Press
Date Published: 10/11/2016
ISBN: 978-1590518144
Available in: Ebook Paperback Hardcover

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »